Conceptual Changes in Perceptions of Health and Illness in Primary School
Age Children 1205
educational psychologist, secondary general school №187 (Nizhniy Novgorod)
Doctor of Psychology, Professor, Department of Psychology, Faculty of Social and Human Sciences, Senior Researcher, Dubna State University, Dubna, Russian Federation, Dubna, Russia
The paper presents results of a longitudinal study on the development of health and illness perceptions in primary school age children (N = 14). As it was substantiated by Vygotsky, school education affects the development of child's spontaneous concepts. The authors thus regard 'health' and 'illness' as everyday concepts that children lack the opportunity to study at school. Accordingly the hypothesis was that the children's statements concerning their perceptions of health and illness become more rich and complex over the course of the first three years of study at school. The data was obtained through the clinical interviews, and each child's responses and arguments on health and illness issues were separately analysed, both qualitatively and quantitatively. The changes in the children's concepts of 'health' and 'illness' proved to be very different in their structure as well as in their content. For instance, in children of the first year of school thoughts on illnesses and illness were more elaborated than those of health, whereas in children of the third year such differences no longer existed. For primary school age children 'health' as a category may be more abstract and less elaborated than 'illness'. The outcomes of the study are finally discussed within the context of the past and contemporary research on conceptual development.
Keywords: children's perceptions, illness, health, primary schoolage children, conceptual development, longitudinal study
Column: Empirical Research
- Arina G.A., Nikolaeva V.V. Psihologiya telesnosti:
metodologicheskie printsipyi i etapyi kliniko-psihologicheskogo analiza //
Psihologiya telesnosti: mezhdu dushoy i telom. M., 2007.
Vyigotskiy L.S. Myishlenie i rech.
Psihologicheskie issledovaniya / Pod red. i so vstup. statey V. Kolbanovskogo.
M.; L., 1934.
Vyigotskiy L.S. Problema obucheniya i
umstvennogo razvitiya v mladshem shkolnom vozraste // Izbrannyie
psihologicheskie issledovaniya. M., 1956.
Kazanskaya K.O. Longityudnoe issledovanie
predstavleniy mladshih shkolnikov ob organah tela // Psihologicheskiy zhurnal
mezhdunarodnogo universiteta prirodyi, obschestva i cheloveka «Dubna». 2011. #
Lozhkin G.V., Rozhdestvenskiy A.Yu. Fenomen
telesnosti v Ya-strukture starsheklassnikov i soderzhanii ih zhiznennyih
proektov // Psihologicheskiy zhurnal. 2004. T. 25. # 2.
Nikolaeva V.V., Arina G.A. Printsipyi
sindromnogo analiza v psihologicheskom izuchenii telesnosti // I
Mezhdunarodnaya konferentsiya pamyati A.R. Lurii. M., 1998.
Nikolaeva V.V., Arina G.A. Ot traditsionnoy
psihosomatiki k psihologii telesnosti // Vestn. Mosk. un-ta. Ser. 14.
Psihologiya. 1996. # 2.
Nikolaeva V.V., Arina G.A.
Kliniko-psihologicheskie problemyi psihologii telesnosti // Psihologicheskiy
zhurnal. 2003. T. 24. # 1.
Obuhova L.F. Vozrastnaya psihologiya. M.,
Thostov A.Sh. Psihologiya telesnosti. M.,
Fuko M. Istoriya seksualnostiIII: Zabota o
sebe. Kiev; M., 1998.
Chebakov Yu.V. Psihologicheskie faktoryi
regulyatsii telesnyih fenomenov u bolnyih saharnyim diabetom tipa 1 // Vestn.
Mosk. unta. Ser. 14. Psihologiya. 2006. # 1.
Bartoszeck A.B., Machado D.Z., Amann Gainotti
M. Graphic representation of organs and organ systems: psychological view
and developmental patterns // Eurasia journal of mathematics, science and
technology education. 2011. Vol. 7 (1).
Bibace R., Walsh M.E. Development of children's
concepts of illness // Pediatrics. 1980. Vol. 66.
Boruchovitch E., Mednick B.R. Cross-cultural
differences in children's concepts of health and illness // Rev. Sau de
Publica. Vol. 31. # 5. 1997.
Carey S. Conceptual Change in Childhood.
Carey S. Conceptual Differences Between
Children and Adults // Mind & Language, 1988.
Crider C. Children's conceptions of the body
interior // R. Bibace and M. Walsh (eds.). Children's Conceptions of Health,
Illness and Bodily Functions. San Francisco, 1983.
Daigle K., Hebert E., Humphries Ch. Children's
understanding of health and healthrelated behavior: the influence of age and
information source // Education. 2007. Vol. 128. #2.
Inagaki K., Hatano G. Young Children's Naive
Thinking About the Biological World. N. Y., 2002.
Inagaki K., Hatano G. Young Children's
Conception of the Biological World // Current Directions in Psychological
Inagaki K., Hatano G. Conceptual Change in
Naive Biology // International Handbook of Research on Conceptual Change / Ed.
by Stella Vosniadou. N. Y., 2008.
International Handbook of Research on Conceptual Change
/ Ed. by S. Vosniadou. N. Y., 2008.
Kalnins I., Love R. Children's concepts of
health and illness — and implications for health education : an overview //
Health Educ. Q. 1982. Vol. 9. # 2—3.
Keil F.C. Concepts, Kinds and Cognitive
Development. Cambridge, MA, 1989.
Meadows S. The child as thinker. L.; N. Y.,
Mobley C.E. Assessment of health knowledge in
preschoolers // Children's health care. 1996. Vol. 25. # 1.
Natapoff J.N. Children's views of health: a
developemntal study // Am. J. Public Health. 1978. Vol. 68.
Natapoff J.N. A developmental analysis of
children's ideas of health // Health Educ. Q. 1982. Vol. 9. # 2—3.
Olvera Ezzell N. et al. The development of
health knowledge in lowincome Mexican—American children // Child.
development. 1994. Vol. 65.
Paterson J., Moss Morris M., Butler S. The
effect of illness experience and demographic factors on children's illness
representations // Psychology of health. 1999. Vol. 14.
Perrin E.C., Gerrity P.S. There's a demon in
your belly: Children's understanding of illness // Pediatrics. 1981. Vol.