Measuring the Risk of Violence in Forensic Psychiatry 1367
Doctor of Psychology, Head of the Laboratory of the psychohygiene and psychoprophylaxis, Federal State Budgetary Institution "V. Serbsky National Medical Research Centre for Psychiatry and Narcology" of the Ministry of Health of the Russian Federation, Moscow, Russia
The article describes the understanding of the term "risk of violence" by foreign forensic psychiatrists, which sometimes is translated as "the risk of aggressive actions". The reasons for the existing problem of successful prediction of socially dangerous acts (SDAs) in patients with severe mental disorders are discussed. The following aspects of risk assessment were considered: clinical, legal and methodological. The risk of violence assessment is a complex analysis of multiple sources of information on various characteristics of the patient and his/her life circumstances. The issue of reliability of such forecasts is discussed. The general and specific goals of violence risk assessment are described. A list of characteristics used by professionals in assessing the risk of violence is provided. Brief description of the strengths and weaknesses of the two approaches currently existing in the field of risk assessment: discretionary and non-discretionary, is provided.
Keywords: risk of violence assessment, mentally ill individuals who committed SDA, actuarial tools, forecast accuracy, clinical judgment, discretionary and non-discretionary approaches.
Column: Juridical Psychology
Voronin V.S., Bulygina V.G. Problema ocenki riska
vnutribol'nichnoi agressii // Problemy profilaktiki obshestvennoi opasnosti
psihicheski bol'nyh: Sb. nauch.trudov/ Pod red. T.B.Dmitrievoi, V.P.Kotova. M.
Mal'ceva M.M., Kotov V.P. Opasnye deistviya psihicheski
bol'nyh. M., 1995.
Polubinskaya S.V. Opasnost' lic, stradayushih
psihicheskimi rasstroistvami, pri naznachenii prinuditel'nyh mer medicinskogo
haraktera: ponyatie ?social'nyi prognoz? // Problemy profilaktiki obshestvennoi
opasnosti psihicheski bol'nyh: Sb. nauch. trudov / Pod red. T.B.Dmitrievoi,
Shishkov S.N. Pravovye aspekty primeneniya prinuditel'nyh
mer medicinskogo haraktera // Prinuditel'noe lechenie v sisteme profilaktiki
obshestvenno opasnyh deistvii psihicheski bol'nyh. M. 1987.
Monahan J., Steadman H.J., Appelbaum P. at al.
Actuarial Model of Violence Risk Assessment for Persons with Mental Disorders
// Psychiatr Serv. 2005. V. 56.
Alfarnes S. A. Risk Assessment of Violence in the
Psychiatry // Norwegian Journal of Psychology. 2003. V.40.
Banks S., Robbins P.C., Silver E., Vesselinov R., Steadman
H.J., Monahan J., Mulvey E.P., Appelbaum P.S., Grisso T., Roth L.H. A
Multiple-models Approach to Violence Risk Assessment among People with Mental
Disorder// Criminal Justice and Behaviour. 2004. V. 31.
Buchanan A. Risk of Violence by Psychiatric Patients:
Beyond the «Actuarial Versus Clinical» Assessment // Psychiatr Serv. 2008. V.
Grann M., Långström N., Yourstone J. SBU-report. Risk
Assessment of Violence in the Psychiatry //Is it Possible to Make Risk
Assessments? A Methaanalyzis. Social Governmental Department, Sweden,
Greg A., Robert A. Incarceration, Homelessness, and Mental
Health: A National Study// Psychiatr Serv.2008. V.59.
Hare R. D., Clark D., Grann M., Thornton D. Psychopathy
and the Predictive Validity of the PCL-R: an International Perspective //
Behaviour Science Law. 2000. V. 18.
Hodgins S. Persistent Violent Offending: What do We Know?
// The British Journal of Psychiatry. 2007. V. 190.
Monahan J. Developing a Clinically Useful Actuarial Tool
for Assessing Violence Risk Advan // Psychiatr. Treat. 2007. V. 13.
Mulvey E.P., Lidz Ch.W. Conditional Prediction: A Model
for Research on Dangerousness to Others in a New Era // International Journal
of Law and Psychiatry. 1995. Vol. 18. № 2.
. Aspects of Basic Management of Offenders with Mental Disorders
Martin Humphreys/ Violence in clinical psychiatry.Amsterdam. 2005. V. 76.
Steadman H., Robbins P.C. Revalidating the Brief Jail
Mental Health Screen to Increase Accuracy for Women // Psychiatr. Serv. 2007.
Webster C., Douglas K.S., Eaves D., Hart S. Assessing Risk
for Violence. Simon Fraser University, 1997.