A Discussion about the Development of Higher Mental Functions in Brazilian Schools: A Portrait of Excluding Inclusion 58
Doctor of Applied Linguistics and Language Studies, Professor at the Portuguese and English Teaching Undergraduate Program and Currently Coordinating the Graduate Program of Education and Health in Childhood and Adolescence, Federal University of São Paulo, Sao Paolo, Brazil
Doctorate Degree in Education from Virginia Tech, and is Currently Full Professor at the Linguistic Department and the Applied Linguistics and Language Studies Graduate Program, Pontifical Catholic University of São-Paulo, Sao Paolo, Brazil
Holds a Doctorate and Master’s Degree in Education and Health in Childhood and Adolescence, Federal University of São Paulo, Sao Paolo, Brazil
This paper aims at providing an overview of Brazilian schools focusing on the development of Vygotsky’s concept of Higher Mental Functions (HMF), especially in the case of students with disabilities. We often see that a lack of appropriate teacher education leads to further excluding students and others involved in the teaching-learning processes — such as the educators themselves, who feel increasingly overwhelmed by their classes of 45 to 60 students, shortage of money and governmental investment. We can even say that Brazilian official schools are immersed in a conflicted-conflicting, alienated-alienating and oppressed-oppressive contradictory reality that is increased by this exclusion-inclusion dichotomy that hinders teachers’ and students’ participation in dialogically organized activities. This diminishes students’ possibilities for developing HMF, which require an argumentative, critical language organization not often accessible to students whilst they continue to be educated on the receiving end of a system that is based on principles of assistance, as are the teachers. With this in mind, the text aims at answering the following question: To what extent are HMF pursued in classrooms allowing young people with(out) specific educational needs to develop (as close as possible) to their fullest potential?
This paper aims at discussing the development of Higher
Mental Functions (HPF) in their relation to the education of children and
adolescents with (or without) specific educational needs or disabilities in
impoverished school contexts mostly in the outskirts of a large city (São
Paulo) in Brazil. We show that certain circumstances might affect or hinder
education, and more specifically the development of HMF, especially in times of
the pandemics1, in a context that encompasses (1) the lack of financial means
for families to support their children’s distance learning in the current
social-educational situation (imposed by COVID-19), for example, and where (2)
schools and universities had to interrupt their activities for months in order
to search for financial support to try to provide students with computers and
internet services for some educational work to be resumed.
Adam J.M., Bonhomme M. L’argumentation publicitaire:
rhétorique de l’éloge et de la persuasion
[Advertising arguments: rhetoric of praise and persuasion].
Paris: Nathan., 1997.
Camporez P. Número de Escolas
públicas “militarizadas” no país cresce sob o
pretexto de enquadrar os alunos [Number of “militarized” public schools in the
country grows under the pretext of framing students]. Goiânia: Epoca. July
23rd, 2018. Available at:
(Accessed 19.15.2020). (In Portuguese).
Fidalgo S.S. Cultural-historical psychology and activity
approach in training specialists in special education. Brazilian teacher
education for inclusive work (or lack thereof). In Yangicher E.V (еd.), The
materials of international symposium. Scientific School of L.S. Vygotsky:
Traditions & Innovations . Moscow, 2016, pp. 76—84.
Fidalgo S.S. (Teacher) education in contexts of
exclusion-inclusion dichotomy: an experience. International Scientific and
Practical Conference: transformation of human potential in the context of the
century. Nizhnii Novgorod, 2017, pp. 46—53.
Fidalgo S.S. Social compensation and the development of
higher psychological functions: theoretical path and methodology for teacher
education. The Geography of Childhood: An Interdisciplinary Synthesis of
Research Approaches and Practices. Vladivostok, Saint. Petersburg, 2018a,
Fidalgo S.S. A linguagem da exclusão e inclusão social na
escola [The language of social exclusion and inclusion at school]. São Paulo:
Editora Unifesp., 2018b. 270 p.
Fidalgo S.S., Magalhães M.C.C. Formação de Professores em
contextos de inclusão: a discussão vygotskiana do conceito de compensação
social [Teacher education in contexts of inclusion: the Vygotskian discussion
of the concept of social compensation]. In Celani M., Medrado B (eds.),
Diálogos sobre inclusão: das
políticas às práticas de
formação de professores em línguas estrangeiras
[Dialogues about inclusion: from policies to practices in the education of
teachers of foreign language]. Campinas, SP: Pontes Editora., 2017, pp.
Fidalgo S.S.; Magalhães M.C.C. The method in Vygotsky:
social compensation to achieve higher psychological functions and social
changes. In Tanzi Neto A; Dafermos M., Liberali F.C. (eds.), Revisiting
Vygotsky for social change: bringing together theory and practice. New
York: Peter Lang. in print.
Freire P. Pedagogia do Oprimido [Pedagogy of the
oppressed]. Rio de Janeiro: Paz e Terra, , 2000.
Freire P. Pedagogia da Autonomia [Pedagogy of autonomy].
Rio de Janeiro: Paz e Terra, 1996.
Gee J.P. New people in new worlds: networks, the new
capitalism and schools. In Kalantzis M., Cope B. (eds.), Multiliteracies:
Literacy learning and the design of social futures. London: Routlege, 2000,
González Rey F.L. O segundo e terceiro momentos da obra de
Vigotsky: história e desenvolvimento das funções psíquicas superiores: a
afirmação de uma teoria histórico-cultural sobre a psique [The second and third
moments of Vigotsky's work: history and development of higher psychological
functions: the affirmation of a cultural-historical theory about the psyche].
In González Rey F.L. (ed.), O pensamento de Vigotsky:
contradições, desdobramentos e desenvolvimento [Vigotsky's
thought: contradictions, outcomes and development]. São Paulo: Hucitec
Editora., 2013, pp. 63—110.
John-Steiner V. Creative Collaboration. Oxford: Oxford
University Press, 2000.
Liberali F.C. Estudos sobre argumentação e suas
implicações para contextos escolares: uma visão panorâmica [Studies about
argumentation and its implications for school contexts: a panoramic view]. In
Liberali F.C. (ed.), Argumentação em contexto escolar
[Argumentation in the school context]. Campinas: Pontes, 2013,
Liberali F.C. Transforming Urban Education in Sãoo Paulo:
Insights into a Critical-Collaborative School Project. DELTA
[online], 2019. Vol.35, no. 3, pp. 1—26. Available at:
https://doi.org/10.1590/1678-460x2019350302. (Accessed 19.15.2020). (In
Magalhães M.C.C. A linguagem na formaзгo de professores
reflexivos e crнticos [Language in the formation of reflective and critical
teachers]. In Magalhгes M.C.C. (ed.), A formacao do professor como um
profissional critico [A formacao do professor como um profissional
critico]. Campinas, SP: Mercado de Letras., 2004, pp. 59—86.
Magalhães M. C. C. O método para Vygotsky: A zona proximal
de desenvolvimento como zona de colaboracao e criticidade criativas [The Method
for Vygotsky: ZPD as a zone of creative collaboration and critical reasoning].
In Schettini R.H., Damianovic M.C., Hawi M.M., Szundy P.T.C. (eds),
Vygotsky: Uma revisita no inнcio do sйculo
XXI [Vygotsky: a review in the early 21st Century]. São Paulo:
Andross., 2009, pp. 53—78.
Magalhães M.C.C. ‘Intervention Research in a Public
Elementary School: A Critical-Collaborative Teacher Education Project on
Reading and Writing’. Outlines — Critical Practice Studies, 2016. Vol.
17, no. 1, pp. 39—61.
Magalhães M.C.C. Formacao Contínua de Professores: A
Organizacao Crítico-Colaborativa para transformacao [Continuing teacher
education: the critical-collaborative organization for transformation].
Linguagem: Estudos e Pesquisas = Language: Studies and Research, 2019.
Vol 22, no. 2. DOI: 10.5216/lep.v22i2.57502. (In Portuguese).
Magalhães M.C.C., Fidalgo S.S. The role of methodological
choices in investigations conducted in school contexts: Critical research on
collaboration in continuing teacher education. In Riika A.; Pöyhönen S. (eds.),
Language in action: Vygotsky and Leontiev legacy today.
Cambridge: Cambridge Scholars Publishing., 2007, pp. 329—352.
Magalhães M.C.C., Fidalgo S.S. Critical collaborative
research: focus on the meaning of collaboration and on mediational tools.
Revista Brasileira de Linguística Aplicada [Brazilian
Journal of Applied Linguistics], 2010. Vol. 10, pp. 773—797.
Magalhães M.C.C., Fidalgo S.S. Reviewing Critical Research
Methodologies for Teacher Education in Applied Linguistics. D.E.L.T.A,
2019. Vol. 35, no. 3, pp. 1—19.
Marx K., Engels F. A ideologia alemã: teses sobre
Feuerbach [German Ideology: Theses on Feuerbach]. São Paulo: Centauro Editora.,
 2004 2005. 1485 p.
Mateus E. Prefácio [Preface]. In Liberali F.C (ed.),
Argumentação em contexto escolar [Argumentation in the
school context]. Campinas: Pontes., 2013, p. 9.
Matos D.S. O ensino da língua portuguesa
escrita para a criaçзa surda em uma perspectiva
bilíngue [Teaching Portuguese written language to deaf
children in a bilingual perspective]. Master’s Thesis. Graduate Program in
Education and Health in Childhood and Adolescence. Guarulhos, SP: UNIFESP,
2017. 199 p.
Ninin M.O.G., Magalhães M.C.C. A linguagem da colaboração
crítica no desenvolvimento da agência de professores de ensino médio em serviço
[The Language of Critical Collaboration in High School teachers’ agency
development]. Alfa: Revista de Linguística [ Alpha:
Journal of Linguistics], 2017. Vol. 61, no. 3, pp. 707—732.
DOI:10.1590/1981-5794-1711-7 (In English).
Pinheiro L.M. Adaptações curriculares na “inclusão”
escolar de alunos surdos: intervenções colaborativas [Curricular adaptations in
the school “inclusion” of deaf students: collaborative interventions].
Doctorate Dissertation Thesis. Graduate Program in Education and Health in
Childhood and Adolescence. Guarulhos, SP: UNIFESP. 2018. 422 p.
Pinheiro L.M., Fidalgo S.S. Adaptações curriculares na
“inclusão” escolar de alunos surdos. [Curricular adaptations in the school
“inclusion” of deaf students: collaborative interventions]. Revista
Brasileira da Pesquisa Sócio-Histórico- Cultural e
da Atividade [Brazilian Journal of Socio-Historical- Cultural Research
and Activity], 2019. Vol. 1, no. 1, pp. 1—15. Available at:
http://revistashc.org/index.php/shc/article/ view/32/1 (Accessed 14.05.2020).
Pinheiro L.M. A “inclusão” escolar de alunos surdos:
colaborações para pensar as adaptações curriculares [School inclusion of deaf
students: collaborations to think about curricular adaptations]. Curitiba:
Appris, 2020. 317 p.
Rieber R.W. (ed.), The collected works of L.S. Vygotsky:
Vol. 2. Fundamentals of Defectology. New York and London: Plenum Press,
1993. 349 p.
Silva E.P.D. As discussões de Vygotsky sobre defectologia:
necessidades para a formação de professores na perspectiva da educação
inclusiva [Vygotsky's discussions on defectology: needs for teacher education
from the perspective of inclusive education]. Doctorate Dissertation Thesis.
Graduate Program in Education and Health in Childhood and Adolescence.
Guarulhos, SP: UNIFESP, 2018. 180 p.
United Nations. Universal Declaration of Human Rights,
1948. Available at:
Vygotsky L.S. Principles of education for physically
handicapped children. In Rieber R.W. (ed.), The collected works of L.S.
Vygotsky: Vol. 2. Fundamentals of Defectology. New York and London: Plenum
Press.,  1993, pp. 65—75.
Vygotski L.S. Introduccion: los problemas fundamentales de
la defectología contemporanea [Introduction: The fundamental problems of
contemporary Defectology]. In Vygotski L.S. (ed.), Obras escogidas V:
Fundamentos de defectología. Madrid: Visór., 
Vygotsky L.S. Compensatory processes in the development of
the retarded child. In Rieber R.W., Carton A.S. (eds.), The collected works
of L.S. Vygotsky: Vol. 2. Fundamentals of Defectology. New York and London:
Plenum Press, [1931a] 1993, pp. 122—138.
Vygotsky L.S. The collective as a factor in the
development of the abnormal child. In Rieber R.W., Carton A.S. (eds.), The
collected works of L.S. Vygotsky: Vol. 2. Fundamentals of Defectology. New
York and London: Plenum Press, [1931b] 1993, pp. 191—208.
Vygotsky L.S. Genesis of higher mental functions. In
Rieber R.W. (ed.), The Collected works of L.S. Vygotsky. New York:
Plenum., 1997, pp. 97—120.