Vygotsky vs. Freud: on the Rethinking of Psychoanalysis in Terms of Cultural-Historical Psychology

The paper traces the dynamics of L.S. Vygotsky’s attitude towards Freud’s theory on the material of Vygotsky’s published works and personal notes. It provides an overall picture of Vygotsky’s critical views on psychoanalysis, including his accounts of both weak and progressive assumptions of Freud’s theory. It has been shown that Vygotsky's polemic with Freud was obviously shaped by the development of cultural- historical psychology and reached the point of a potential rivalry between their research programs in late 1932. The paper focuses on the perspectives of rethinking classical psychoanalysis in the context of the ideas of Vygotsky’s last period of life and work (1932—1934), namely, the idea of consciousness as a dynamic system of meaning, the concept of the field of meaning, the relationship between normal and abnormal development, and the idea of freedom as the main feature of human existence. It is stated that Vygotsky did not seek to eliminate any competing theories (in particular, psychoanalysis), but rather remained in dialogue with them and contributed to making their foundations more clear.

1. Birenbaum G.V., Zeigarnik B.V. K dinamicheskomu analizu rasstroistv myshleniya [To dymanic analisys of thought diturbances]. Sovetskaya nevropatologiya, psikhiatriya i gigiena [Soviet neuropathology, psychiatry and psychohygiene], 1935, vol. 4, no. 6, pp. 75—98.
2. Veresov  N.N.  Eksperimental’no-geneticheskii  metod i psikhologiya soznaniya: v poiskakh utrachennogo (stat’ya vtoraya) [Experimental genetic method and psychology of consciousness: in search of the lost (part two)]. Kul’turno- istoricheskaya psikhologiya [Cultural-historical psychology], 2015, vol. 11, no. 1, pp. 117—126. (In Russ., abstr. in Engl.). doi:10.17759/chp.2015110113
3. Voloshinov V.N. Po tu storonu sotsial’nogo: O fre- idizme [Beyond the social: on Freudianism]. Zvezda [The star], 1925, no. 5, pp. 186—214.
4. Voloshinov V.N. Freidizm. Kriticheskii ocherk [Freud- ianism: A Critical Essay]. Moscow; Leningrad: G.I.Z., 1927. 164 p.
5. Vygotskii L.S. Igra i ee rol’ v psikhicheskom razvitii re- benka [The play and its role in the mental development of the child]. In Psikhologiya razvitiya [Developmental psychology]. Saint-Petersburg: Piter, 2001, pp. 56—79.
6. Vygotskii L.S. Konkretnaya psikhologiya cheloveka [Concrete human psychology]. In Psikhologiya razvitiya che- loveka [Psychology of human development]. Moscow: Eksmo, 2005, pp. 1020—1038.
7. Vygotskii L.S.  K  probleme  psikhologii  shizofrenii [On the problem of psychology of schizophrenia]. Sovetskaya nevropatologiya, psikhiatriya i psikhogigiena [Soviet neuro- pathology, psychiatry and psychohygiene], 1932, vol. 1, no. 8, pp. 352—364.
8. Vygotskii L.S. Lektsii po pedologii [Lectures on pedol- ogy]. Izhevsk: Publ. “Udmurtskii universitet”, 2001. 304 p.
9. Vygotskii L.S. Psikhika, soznanie i bessoznatel’noe [Psyche, consciousness and unconsciousness]. In Kornilov K.N. (ed.) Elementy obshchei psikhologii [Elements of general psychology]. Moscow: Publ. B.Z.O. pri pedfake 2-go MGU, 1930, vol. 4, pp. 48—61.
10. Vygotskii L.S. Problema umstvennoi otstalosti [The problem of mental retardation]. In Problemy defektologii [Prob- lems of defectology]. Moscow: Prosveshchenie, 1995, pp. 426— 450.
11. Vygotskii L.S. Psikhologiya iskusstva [Psychology of art]. Ivanov V.V. (ed.). 3-e izd. Moscow: Iskusstvo, 1986. 573 p.
12. Vygotskii L.S. Sobranie sochinenii: v 6 t. T. 1. Voprosy teorii i istorii psikhologii [Collected Works: in 6 vol. Vol. 1. Questions of the theory and hystory of psychology]. Moscow: Pedagogika, 1982. 488 p.
13. Vygotskii L.S. Sobranie sochinenii: v 6 t. T. 2. Proble- my obshchei psikhologii [Collected Works: in 6 vol. Vol. 2. Prob- lems of general psychology]. Moscow: Pedagogika, 1982. 504 p.
14. Vygotskii L.S. Sobranie sochinenii: v 6 t. T. 3. Proble- my razvitiya psikhiki [Collected Works: in 6 vol. Vol. 3. Problems of development of the mind]. Moscow: Pedagogika, 1983. 368 p.
15. Vygotskii L.S. Sobranie sochinenii: v 6 t. T. 4. Detskaya psikhologiya [Collected Works: in 6 vol. Vol. 4. Child psychol- ogy]. Moscow: Pedagogika, 1984. 433 p.
16. Vygotskii L.S. Sobranie sochinenii: v 6 t. T. 5. Osnovy defektologii [Collected Works: in 6 vol. Vol 5. The fundamentals of defectology]. Moscow: Pedagogika, 1983. 369 p.
17. Vygotskii L.S. Son i snovideniya [Sleeping and dreams]. In Kornilov (ed.) Elementy obshchei psikhologii [Ele- ments of general psychology]. Moscow: Publ. B.Z.O. pri pedfake 2-go MGU, 1930, pp. 62—75.
18. Vygotskii  L.S.,  Luriya  A.R.   Predislovie   [Preface]. In Freid Z. Po tu storonu printsipa udovol’stviya [Beyond the pleasure principle]. Moscow: Sovremennye problemy,  1925, pp. 3—16.
19. Gonzales A. “Freid v Vygotskom. Bessoznatel’noe i yazyk” [“Freud In Vygotsky. Unconscious and Language”]. Kul’turno-istoricheskaya psikhologiya [Cultural-Historical Psy- chology], 2007, no. 1, pp. 114—120. (In Russ., abstr. in Engl.).
20. Zavershneva E.Yu. Dve linii razvitiya kategorii “smysl” v rabotakh L.S. Vygotskogo [Two lines of the development of the category “sense” in L.S. Vygotsky’s works]. Voprosy psik- hologii [Question of psychology], 2015, no. 3, pp. 116—132. (In Russ., abstr. in Engl.).
21. Zavershneva E.Yu. Zapisnye knizhki, zametki, nauch- nye dnevniki L.S. Vygotskogo: rezul’taty issledovaniya se- meinogo arkhiva [Notebooks, notes and scientific journals of L.S. Vygotsky: research of the family archive]. Voprosy psik- hologii [Question of psychology], 2008, no. 2, pp. 120—136. (In Russ., abstr. in Engl.).
22. Zavershneva E.Yu.  “Klyuch  k  psikhologii  chelove- ka”: kommentarii k bloknotu L.S. Vygotskogo iz bol’nitsy “Zakhar’ino” (1926 g.) [“The key to human psychology”: com- mentary on L.S. Vygotsky’s notebook from Zakharino hospital (1926)]. Voprosy psikhologii [Question of  psychology],  2009, no 3, pp. 123—141. (In Russ., abstr. in Engl.).
23. Zavershneva E.Yu. Predstavleniya o smyslovom pole v teorii dinamicheskikh smyslovykh sistem L.S. Vygotskogo [The notion of semantic field in L.S. Vygotsky’s theory of dy- namic semantic system]. Voprosy psikhologii [Question of psy- chology], 2015, no. 4, pp. 119—135. (In Russ., abstr. in Engl.).
24. Zavershneva E.Yu. Problema svobody kak otlichitel’noi kharakteristiki cheloveka v rabotakh L.S. Vygotskogo [The problem of freedom as a distinctive feature of human in L.S. Vy- gotsky’s works]. Voprosy psikhologii [Question of psychology], 2015, no. 5, pp. 89—105. (In Russ., abstr. in Engl.).
25. Lakatos I. Fal’sifikatsiya i metodologiya nauchno- issledovatel’skikh program [Falsification and the methodol- ogy of scientific research programs]. Moscow: Medium, 1995. 236 p. (In Russ.).
26. Luriya A.R. Psikhoanaliz kak sistema monisticheskoi psikhologii [Psychoanalysis as a system of monistic psychol- ogy]. In Kornilov K.N. (ed.) Psikhologiya i marksizm [Psychol- ogy and marxizm]. Leningrad: G.I.Z., 1925, pp. 47—80.
27. Samukhin N.V., Birenbaum G.V., Vygotskii L.S. K vo- prosu o strukture dementsii pri bolezni Pika [To the issue of dementia in Pick’s disease]. Sovetskaya nevropatologiya, psikh- iatriya i psikhogigiena [Soviet neuropathology, psychiatry and psychohygiene], 1934, vol. 3, no. 6, pp. 97—136.
28. Ulybina E.V. Znakovoe oposredovanie v kul’turno- istoricheskoi teorii i psikhoanalize [Sigh mediation in cultural- historical theory and psychoanalysis]. Psikhologicheskii zhurnal [Psychological journal], 2004, vol. 25, no. 6, pp. 64—72. (In Russ., abstr. in Engl.).
29. Freid Z. Bessoznatel’noe [Unconsiousness]. In Os- novnye psikhologicheskie teorii v psikhoanalize. Ocherk istorii psikhoanaliza [Main psychological theories of psychoanalysis. Essays on the history of psychoanalysis]. Saint-Petersburg: Ale- teiya, 1998, pp. 151—193. (In Russ.).
30. Freid Z. Vvedenie v psikhoanaliz. Lektsii [Introducto- ry lectures into psychoanalysis]. Moscow: Nauka, 1991. 456 p. (In  Russ.).
31. Freud S. Neue folge der vorlesungen zur einführung in die psychoanalyse [New introductory lectures on psychoanalysis]. Wien: Internationaler Psychoanalitischer Verlag, 1933. 254 p.
32. Kozulin A. The concept of regression and vygotskian developmental theory. Developmental review, 1990. No.  10, pp. 218—238.
33. Pešić J., Baucal A.  Vygotsky and psychoanalysis:  To- ward dialogue. Journal of Russian and East European Psychol- ogy, 1996. Vol. 34, no. 1, pp. 33—39.
34. Van der Veer R. Tatyana on the couch: the vicissitudes of psychoanalysis in Russia. In S. Salvatore (eds.) Cultural psy- chology and  psychoanalysis: pathway  to synthesis.  Charlotte, N.C.: Information Age Publishing, 2011, pp. 49—55.
35. Wertsch J.V. A meeting of paradigms: Vygotsky and psychoanalysis. Contemporary Psychoanalysis, 1990. Vol. 26, no. 1, pp. 53—73.
36. Wilson A., Weinstein L. An investigation into some implications of a Vygotskian perspective on the origins of the mind: psychoanalysis and Vygotskian psychology, Part I. Jour- nal of the American Psychoanalytic Association, 1992. No. 40, pp. 357—387.
37. Wilson A. Weinstein L. Language and the psychoana- lytic process: Psychoanalysis and Vygotskian psychology, Part II. Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association, 1992. No. 40, pp. 725—760.
38. Wilson A., Weinstein L. Language, thought, and interi- orization: A Vygotskian and psychoanalytic perspective. Con- temporary Psychoanalysis, 1990. Vol. 26, no. 1, pp. 24—41.
39. Wilson A., Weinstein L. The transference and the zone of proximal development. Journal of the American Psychoana- lytic Association, 1996. Vol. 44, no. 1, pp. 167—199.
40. Zavershneva E. The problem  of consciousness in  Vy- gotsky’s cultural-historical psychology. In Yasnitsky A. (eds.) The Cambridge handbook of cultural-historical psychology. Cam- bridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, 2014, pp. 63—100.