Psychologically Traumatic Situation as a Formal Element of an Offence under Article 106 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation (Murder by a Mother of Her Newborn Child)

The study is aimed at finding general grounds of criminal responsibility for neonaticide (murder by a mother of her own newborn child). The formal crime signs listed in article 106 of CCRF have been analysed. The theoretical analysis is supplemented with a study of 40 criminal cases. It was concluded that the common ground for inclusion of the three formal elements of the crime (differing in a number of criteria) is the mother's limited capability to consciously and arbitrarily control her behavior while murdering her newborn child. In the first case, the main factor limiting this legally significant capability is a legislator-presumed specific psychophysical condition of the parturient woman, in the second case it is a specific emotional state caused by a psychologically traumatic event associated with pregnancy and childbirth. The third case is a mental disorder not excluding sanity. A remark about the baby-murdering mother's special emotional condition limiting her capability to be aware of her actions (and control them) has been suggested for inclusion in the text of the article. The advisability of obligatory prescription for a comprehensive forensic psychological and psychiatric examination has been substantiated when the offence is categorized under article 106 of CCRF.

1. Alenkin N.E. Voprosy` ugolovnoj otvetstvennosti za detoubijstvo (st. 106 UK RF) [Questions of criminal responsibility for infanticide (article 106 of the criminal code of the Russian Federation)]. Vestnik Moskovskogo universiteta . Ser.11. Pravo [Bulletin of the Moscow University. Ser.11. Law], 2013, no. 5, pp. 87-101.
2. Antonyan Yu.M., Goncharova M.V., Kurguzkina E.B. Ubijstvo mater`yu novorozhdennogo rebenka: ugolovno-pravovy`e i kriminologicheskie problemy` [Mother's murder of a newborn child: criminal law and criminological problems]. LexRussica. № 3 (136). 2018, pp. 95-114.
3. Bagmet A.M., Troshhanovich A.V. K voprosu ob otvetstvennosti za prestuplenie, predusmotrennoe st. 106 UK RF [On the issue of liability for a crime under article 106 of the criminal code of the Russian Federation]. Rossijskij sledovatel` [Russian investigator], 2014, no. 1, pp. 18-20.
4. Borodin S.V. Prestupleniya protiv zhizni [Crimes against life]. Moscow.: Yurist, 2000. 620 p.
5. Brutman V.I., Radionova M.S. Formirovanie privyazannosti materi k rebenku v period beremennosti [Formation of mother's attachment to the child during pregnancy ]. Voprosy` psixologii [Questions of psychology], 1998, no. 7, pp. 38-47.
6. Gorbatova M.A., Sergeeva A.A. Privilegiruyushhee obstoyatel`stvo v sostave ubijstva mater`yu novorozhdennogo rebenka [A privileged circumstance in the composition of the murder of a newborn child by a mother]. Zhurnal pravovy`h i e`konomicheskih issledovanij [Journal of legal and economic research], 2019, no. 3, pp. 39-44.
7. Grubova E.I. Problemy` otvetstvennosti za ubijstvo mater`yu novorozhdennogo rebenka v rossijskom i zarubezhnom ugolovnom zakonodatel`stve: avtoref. dis. … kand. yurid. nauk [Problems of responsibility for the murder of a newborn child by a mother in Russian and foreign criminal legislation]. Ph. D. (Law) Thesis] Moscow, 2009. 27 p.
8. Dashkevich N.A. Svojstva lichnosti zhenshhiny`, sovershivshej prestuplenie, predusmotrennoe st. 106 UK RF [Personal characteristics of a woman who has committed a crime under article 106 of the criminal code of the Russian Federation]. Vestnik IrGTU [IrGTU Bulletin]. 2011. No. 9 (56), pp. 249-253.
9. Dmitrieva T.B., Kachaeva M.A., Safuanov F.S. Kompleksnaya sudebnaya psixologo-psixiatricheskaya e`kspertiza psixicheskogo sostoyaniya materi, obvinyaemoj v ubijstve novorozhdennogo rebyonka: Rukovodstvo dlya vrachej i psixologov [Comprehensive forensic psychological and psychiatric examination of the mental state of a mother accused of murdering a newborn child: a guide for doctors and psychologists]. Moscow: Publ. GNC SSP im. V.P. Serbskogo, 2001. 44 p.
10. Dyadyun K. V. Ubijstvo mater`yu novorozhdennogo rebenka: voprosy` ob``ektivnoj storony` sostava [Murder of a newborn child by a mother: questions of the objective side of the composition]. Advokat [Lawyer]. 2013. No. 11, pp. 14-19.
11. Zhivodrova N. A., Andriyanceva Yu. V. Ubijstvo mater`yu novorozhdennogo rebenka v usloviyax psixotravmiruyushhej situacii: analiz sudebnoj praktiki [Murder of a newborn child by a mother in a psychotraumatic situation: analysis of judicial practice]. E`lektronny`j nauchny`j zhurnal «Nauka. Obshhestvo. Gosudarstvo» [Electronic scientific journal "Science. Society. State»]. 2019. T. 7. No. 3 (27), pp.139-143. http://esj.pnzgu.ru
12. Karasova A.L. Ubijstvo mater`yu novorozhdennogo rebenka: teoretiko-prikladny`e aspekty` otvetstvennosti po st. 106 UK RF: avtoref. dis. … kand. yurid. Nauk [Murder of a newborn child by a mother: theoretical and applied aspects of responsibility under article 106 of the criminal code of the Russian Federation. Ph. D. (Law) Thesis]. Rostov-na-Donu, 2003. 26 p.
13. Kommentarij k Ugolovnomu kodeksu Rossijskoj Federacii / Pod red. Yu.I. Skuratova, V.M. Lebedeva [In. Yu.I. Skuratov, V.M. Lebedev (eds.) Commentary on the criminal code of the Russian Federation]. Moscow, 1996. 592 p.
14. Krasikov A. N. Ugolovno-pravovaya oxrana politicheskix, grazhdanskix i iny`x konstitucionny`x prav i svobod cheloveka i grazhdanina v Rossii [Criminal law protection of political, civil and other constitutional rights and freedoms of a person and citizen in Russia]. Saratov: Publ. Saratov. un-ta, 2000. 99 p.
15. Kruglikov L.L. Prestupleniya protiv lichnosti [Crimes against persons]. Yaroslavl`: Publ. YarGU, 1998. 76 p.
16. Lukomskaya A.S. Lichnost` obvinyaemoj (podozrevaemoj) v dokazy`vanii ubijstva mater`yu novorozhdennogo rebenka, sovershennoe v usloviyax psixotravmiruyushhej situacii [The identity of the accused (suspect) in proving the murder of a newborn child by the mother, committed in a psychotraumatic situation]. Vestnik Udmurtskogo universiteta [Bulletin of the Udmurt University]. 2011. No. 3, pp.146-149.
17. Murzina L.I. Ubijstvo mater`yu novorozhdennogo rebenka: ugolovno-pravovy`e i kriminologicheskie problemy`: avtoref. dis. … kand. yurid. Nauk [Mother's murder of a newborn child: criminal law and criminological problems. Ph. D. (Law) Thesis]. Saratov, 2009. 21 p.
18. Muxacheva I.M. Sostoyanie psixicheskogo rasstrojstva, ne isklyuchayushhego vmenyaemosti v sootvetstvii so st. 106 UK RF [The state of a mental disorder that does not exclude sanity in accordance with article 106 of the criminal code of the Russian Federation]. Aktual`ny`e problemy` rossijskogo prava [Actual problems of Russian law]. 2017. No. 2 (75), pp. 183-190.
19. Nazarenko G.V. Differenciaciya ugolovnoj otvetstvennosti i iny`x mer ugolovno-pravovogo xaraktera za detoubijstvo [Differentiation of criminal responsibility and other measures of criminally-legal character for infanticide]. Kriminalist`` [Criminalist]. 2019. No. 1 (26), pp. 31-34.
20. Natura A.I., Zlobina L.A. Social`no-psixologicheskij status materi-ubijcy novorozhdennogo rebenka kak e`lement kriminalisticheskoj xarakteristiki prestupleniya [Socio-psychological status of the mother-killer of a newborn child as an element of criminalistic characteristics of the crime]. Teoriya i praktika obshhestvennogo razvitiya [Theory and practice of social development]. 2017. No. 12, pp. 134-138.
21. Plaksina T.A. Reglamentaciya otvetstvennosti za ubijstvo novorozhdennogo rebenka v ugolovnom zakonodatel`stve Rossii, Kazaxstana i Ky`rgy`zstana [Regulation of responsibility for the murder of a newborn child in the criminal legislation of Russia, Kazakhstan and Kyrgyzstan]. Altajskij yuridicheskij vestnik [Altai legal Bulletin]. 2015. No. 3 (11), pp.77-81.
22. Popov A.N. Ubijstvo mater`yu novorozhdennogo rebenka (st. 106 UK RF) [Murder of a newborn child by a mother (article 106 of the criminal code of the Russian Federation)]. Saint Petersburg.: SPbYuI General`noj prokuratury` Rossijskoj Federacii. 2001. 68 p.
23. Popov A.N. Prestupleniya protiv lichnosti pri smyagchayushhix obstoyatel`stvax [Crimes against the person under extenuating circumstances]. Saint Petersburg.: Yuridicheskij centr Press. 2001. 465 p.
24. Ramazanov T.B. Materi-detoubijcy: kto oni s tochki zreniya kriminalistiki? [Child-killing mothers: who are they from the point of view of criminology?]. Yuridicheskij vestnik Dgu [DSU legal Bulletin]. 2015. No. 1, pp. 109-114.
25. Safuanov F. S. E`kspertiza psixicheskogo sostoyaniya materi, obvinyaemoj v ubijstve novorozhdennogo rebenka [ Examination of the mental state of a mother accused of murdering a newborn child]. Rossijskaya yusticiya [Russian justice system]. 1998. No. 3, pp. 29-30.
26. Safuanov F.S. Sudebno-psixologicheskaya e`kspertiza v ugolovnom processe [Forensic psychological examination in criminal proceedings]. Moscow: Gardarika, Smy`sl.1998, 192 p.
27. Safuanov F.S. Sudebno-psixologicheskaya e`kspertiza: Uchebnik dlya akademicheskogo bakalavriata [It is judicial-psychological examination: a Textbook for academic bachelor degree]. Moscow: Publ. Yurajt. 2014. 421p.
28. Ugolovny`j Kodeks RF Novaya redakciya i kommentarii k nej [The criminal Code of the Russian Federation. New version and comments to it]. https://ukrf24.ru/statia-106-uk.
29. Ugolovny`j kodeks Shvejczarii [Criminal code of Switzerland]. Saint Petersburg.: Yuridicheskij centr Press. 2002. 350 p.
30. Chixradze A.M. Teoreticheskie osnovy` formirovaniya yuridicheskogo ponyatiya «privilegirovannoe ubijstvo» [Theoretical basis for the formation of the legal concept of «privileged killing»]. Agrarnoe i zemel`noe pravo [Agrarian and land law]. 2019. No. 12 (180), pp. 140-144.
31. Chemerinskij K.V. Ob``ektivnaya storona ubijstva mater`yu novorozhdennogo rebenka [Objective side of the mother's murder of a newborn child]. Sovremenny`e nauchny`e issledovaniya [Modern scientific research]. 2011. No.2, pp. 20-32.
32. Shved N. A. Ubijstvo mater`yu novorozhdennogo rebenka: podxody` k ustanovleniyu otvetstvennosti v Respublike Belarus` i Rossijskoj Federacii [Mother's murder of a newborn child: approaches to establishing responsibility in the Republic of Belarus and the Russian Federation]. Kriminalist`` [Criminalist]. 2019. No. 1 (26), pp. 99-103.
33. Shikula I.R. Ubijstvo mater`yu novorozhdennogo rebenka: problemny`e voprosy` kvalifikacii i tendencii resheniya [Mother's murder of a newborn child: problematic issues of qualification and solution trends]. Ugolovnaya politika i pravoprimenitel`naya praktika [Criminal policy and law enforcement practice]. Saint Petersburg.: Centr nauchno-informacionny`x texnologij «Asterion». 2019, pp. 298-304.