Critical Challenges in Cultural-Historical Activity Theory: the Urgency of Agency 1127
The article addresses the challenge of conceptualizing agency within a non-dichotomous, dialectical approach that gives full credit to the social roots of agency and does justice to it being an achievement of togetherness possible only in a communal world shared with others. Critical steps in this direction are undertaken by the Transformative Activist Stance (TAS) approach advanced by this article’s author and further developed and applied to various topics by scholars from many parts of the world. This approach is firmly rooted in cultural-historical activity theory yet also moves beyond it in overcoming some of its impasses. The core elements of TAS are discussed to reveal how they coalesce on the nexus of social practices of self- and world-making. Agency is the process that enacts this nexus of ongoing, ceaseless social-individual transformations whereby people simultaneously, in one process, co-create their world and themselves so that each individual person makes a difference and matters in the totality of social practices. Ethical-political entailments of TAS are discussed to combat the legacy of passivity and inequality still permeating psychology and neighboring fields.
In this paper, I address what can be consider to be one of
today’s major challenges in theorizing human development and mind including
within cultural-historical activity theory and related approaches such as
sociocultural, cultural, and critical frameworks in psychology, education,
literary theory, and communication studies, among others. This challenge is how
to conceptualize human agency yet not slip into the pitfalls of traditional
approaches premised on assumptions about agency as an autonomous, solipsistic
achievement of isolated individuals understood either as “free-will” subjects
or, on another spectrum of views, as puppets of extraneous influences at the
whim of powerful forces outside of one’s control and even awareness.
Amsler S. The education of radical democracy. London:
Arendt H. The life of the mind. San Diego, CA: Harvest
Arievitch I. M. Beyond the brain: An agentive active
activity perspective on mind, development, and learning. Boston/Rotterdam:
Sense Publishers, 2017.
Arievitch I. M., Stetsenko A. The “magic of signs”: The
developmental trajectory of cultural mediation. In A. Yasnitsky, R. van der
Veer and M. Ferrari (Eds.), The Cambridge Handbook of Cultural-Historical
Psychology (pp. 217—244). New York, NY: Cambridge University Press,
Bartolini Bussi M.G. Early years mathematics: Semiotic and
cultural meditation. In Carlsen M. (eds.), Mathematics education in the
early years. Cham, Switzerland: Springer (pp. 1—22), 2020.
Butler J. Gender trouble: Feminism and the subversion of
identity. New York, NY: Routledge, 1999.
Caffreya G., Rogers R. Students taking social action:
Critical literacy practices through school-as-museum learning. Berkeley
Review of Education, 2018, 8 (1), pp. 83—114.
Castañeda C. Figurations: Child, bodies, worlds. Durham,
NC: Duke University Press, 2002.
Cavanagh C. Osip Mandelstam and the modernist creation of
tradition. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 1995.
Chimirri N.A., Pedersen S. Toward a
transformative-activist coexploration of the world? Emancipatory co-research in
Psychology from the standpoint of the subject. Annual Review of Critical
Psychology, 2019, 16, 605—633.
Clark A. Supersizing the mind: Embodiment, action, and
cognitive extension. New York: Oxford University Press, 2008.
Cole M. Cultural psychology: A once and future discipline.
Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1996.
Cole M., Engeström Y. A cultural- historical approach to
distributed cognition. In Salomon G. (ed.), Distributed cognitions (pp.
1—46). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1993.
Collins C., McCrory M., Mackenzie, M., McCartney G. Social
theory and health inequalities: Critical realism and a transformative activist
stance? Social Theory & Health, 2015, 1—20.
Costall A. Introspectionism and the mythical origins of
scientific psychology. Consciousness and Cognition, 2006, 15,
Darley S. Learning as a process of personal-social
transformation: Volunteering activity in health and social care charities.
Mind, Culture, and Activity, 2018, 25, 199—215.
Eagleton T. Why Marx was right. New Haven, CT: Yale
University Press, 2011.
Edwards A. Relational agency: learning to be a resourceful
practitioner. Int. J. Educ. Res., 2005, 43, 168—182.
Enciso P., Edmiston B., Volz A., Lee B., Sivashankar N.
“I’m trying to save some lives here! Critical dramatic inquiry in the aftermath
of Hurricane Katrina. English Teaching: Practice & Critique, 2016,
15 (3), 333—354.
Engeström Y. Learning by expanding: An
activity-theoretical approach to developmental research. Helsinki:
Eteläpelto A., Vähäsantanen K., Hökk Ä.P., Paloniemi S.
What is agency? Conceptualizing professional agency at work. Educational
Research Review, 2013, 10, 45—65. DOI:10.1016/j.edurev.2013.05.001
Etengoff C. Transvlogs: online communication tools for
transformative agency and development. Mind, Culture, and Activity,
2019, 26(2), 138—155. DOI: 10.1080/10749039.2019.1612438
Fanon F. Black Skins, White Masks (Translated by C.L.
Markham). New York: Monthly Review Press, 1967.
Friedman S.R. et al. Theory, measurement and hard times:
Some issues for HIV/AIDS research. AIDS and Behavior, 2013,
17, 1915—1925. DOI:10.1007/s10461-013- 0475-3
Gade S., Forsgren T.L. Realizing transformative agency and
student identity: meaningful practical activity based formative intervention at
grade eight. Cultural Studies of Science Education. Published online 22.
January 2019. DOI:10.1007/s11422-018-9907-8
Garraway J., Morkel J. Learning in sites of practice
through a CHAT lens paradigms. Journal for Research and Innovation in
Teaching and Learning, 2017, 20, pp. 40—47.
Gergen K.J. Relational being: Beyond self and community.
Oxford University Press, 2009.
Gibson M. Crafting communities of practice: the
relationship between making and learning. International Journal of
Technology and Design Education, 2019, 29, 25—35.
Goessling K.P. Youth participatory action research,
trauma, and the arts: designing youthspaces for equity and healing.
International Journal of Qualitative Studies in Education, 2020, 33 (1),
12—31, DOI: 10.1080/09518398.2019.1678783
Hichenberg N.M. Emily meets the world: Child agency
encounters adult imperialism. Dissertation Abstracts International Section A:
Humanities and Social Sciences, 2019. Vol. pp. 80 (11-A).
Holland D., Lachicotte W., Skinner D., Cain C. Identity
and agency in cultural worlds. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press,
Holland D., Lave J. Social practice theory and the
historical production of persons. Actio: An International Journal of Human
Activity Theory, 2009, 2, 1—15.
James W. Pragmatism: A new name for some old ways of
thinking, 1907. Available at: www. gutenberg.org/ fi les/ 5116/ 5116-h/
5116-h.htm (accessed July 10, 2016).
Jameson F. Marx’s purloined letter. New Left
Review, 1995, 209, 75—109.
King M.L., Jr. Commencement address for Oberlin College,
June, 1965. Oberlin, Ohio. Available at: www. oberlin.edu/ external/ EOG/
BlackHistoryMonth/ MLK/ CommAddress.html (accessed July 10, 2016).
Kumpulainen K., Kajamaa A., Rajala A. Understanding
educational change: agency-structure dynamics in a novel design and making
environment. Dig. Educ. Rev., 2018, 33, 26—38.
Lave J., Wenger E. Situated learning: Legitimate
peripheral participation. New York: Cambridge University Press, 1991.
Lavell A., Mansilla E., Maskrey A., Ramirez F. The social
construction of the COVID-19 pandemic: Disaster, risk accumulation and public
policy. LA RED (Network for Social Studies on Disaster Prevention in Latin
America), 2020. Available at:
(Accessed April 21, 2020).
Leont'ev D.A. Chelovek i zhiznennyi mir: ot ontologii k
fenomenologii. Kul'turno-istoricheskaya psikhologiya, 2019, 15, no. 1,
pp. 25—34. Леонтьев Д.А. Человек и жизненный мир: от онтологии к феноменологии.
Культурно-историческая психология, 2019, 15. № 1. С. 25—34.
Lickliter R., Honeycutt H. Biology, development, and human
systems. In Lerner R.M. (ed.), Handbook of child psychology and
developmental science (pp. 162—207). New York: Wiley, 2015.
Mandel'shtam O.E. (1990). Soch. v 2 tt. T. 2. M.:
Khudozhestvennaya literatura. Elektronnaya publikatsiya — RVB, 2010—2020.
Versiya 2.0 ot 3 oktyabrya 2019 g. Available at:
(Accessed April 21, 2020). Мандельштам О.Э. (1990). Соч. в 2 тт. Т. 2. М.:
Художественная литература. Электронная публикация — РВБ, 2010—2020. Версия 2.0
от 3 октября 2019 г. Available at:
(Accessed April 21, 2020).
Martínez-Roldán C.M. (in press). Narrating Erasure,
Narrating Agency. Towards A Transformative Activist Stance Educational
Miller G. Growing pains for fMRI. Science, 2008,
Mol A. Ontological politics: A word and some questions. In
J. Law and J.Hassard (eds.), Actor network theory and after (pp. 74—89).
Oxford: Blackwell, 1999.
Morens D.M., Daszak P., Taubenberger J.K. Escaping
Pandora’s Box — Another Novel Coronavirus. New England Journal of
Medicine,2020, 382, 1293—1295. DOI:10.1056/ NEJMp2002106
Morson G.S., Emerson C. Mikhail Bakhtin: Creation of a
prosaics. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press, 1990.
Overton W. F. Embodiment from a relational perspective. In
Overton W. F (eds.), Developmental perspectives on embodiment and
consciousness (pp. 1—18). New York: Erlbaum, 2008.
Oyama S. Evolution’s eye. Durham, NC: Duke University
Podlucká D. Transformative anti-ableist pedagogy for
social justice: Charting a critical agenda for inclusive education. Outlines
— critical practice studies, 2020. Vol. 21, no. 1, 69—97.
Roediger H.L. What happened to behaviorism? APS
Rogoff B. The cultural nature of human development. New
York: Oxford University Press, 2003.
Sales L.L., Vianna E., Fontes F.F., Yasui S. (2020).
Prefigurative Brazilian ativismo through the lens of the transformative
activist stance: Renewing radical political imagination through
“collectividual” agency. Mind, Culture, and Activity, 2020.
Sannino A. The emergence of transformative agency and
double stimulation: Activity-based studies in the Vygotskian tradition.
Learning, Culture, and Social Interaction, 2014, 4, 1—3.
Sawchuk P., Stetsenko A. Sociology for a non-canonical
activity theory: Exploring intersections and complementarities. Mind,
Culture and Activity, 2008, 15 (4), 339—360.
Sawyer J., Stetsenko A. Lev Vygotsky’s approach to
language and speech. In P. Brooks and V. Kempe (eds.), Encyclopedia of
Language Development (pp. 663—666). Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE, 2014.
Sawyer J., Stetsenko A. Revisiting and problematizing Marx
and Vygotsky: A transformative approach to speech internalization. Language
Sciences, 2019, 70, 143—154.
Stetsenko A. Introduction to “Tool and sign” by Lev
Vygotsky. In R. Rieber & D. Robinson (Eds.), Essential Vygotsky (pp.
501—512). NY: Kluwer Academic/Plenum, 2004.
Stetsenko A. Activity as object-related: Resolving the
dichotomy of individual and collective types of activity. Mind, Culture,
& Activity, 2005, 12 (1), 70—88.
Stetsenko A. From relational ontology to transformative
activist stance: Expanding Vygotsky's (CHAT) project. Cultural Studies of
Science Education, 2008, 3, 465—485.
Stetsenko A. Vygotsky and the conceptual revolution in
developmental sciences: Towards a unified (non-additive) account of human
development. In Fleer M. (eds.), World Year Book of Education. Constructing
childhood: Global-local policies and practices (pp. 125—142). London:
Stetsenko A. Teaching-learning and development as activist
projects of historical Becoming: Expanding Vygotsky’s approach to pedagogy.
Pedagogies: An International Journal, 2010, 5 (1), 6—16.
Stetsenko A. Darwin and Vygotsky on development: An
exegesis on human nature. In Kontopodis M. (eds.), Children, Culture and
Education. (Springer/ Series: International Perspectives on Early Childhood
Education and Development) (pp. 25—41). New York: Springer, 2011.
Stetsenko A. Personhood: An activist project of historical
Becoming through collaborative pursuits of social transformation. New Ideas
in Psychology, 2012, 30, 144—153.
Stetsenko A. The challenge of individuality in
cultural-historical activity theory: “Collectividual” dialectics from a
transformative activist stance. Outlines — Critical Practice Studies,
2013a, 14 (2), 7—28.
Stetsenko A. Theorizing personhood for the world in
transition and change: Reflections from a transformative activist stance. In
Martin J. (eds.), The Psychology of personhood: Philosophical, historical,
social-developmental, and narrative perspectives (pp. 181—203). Cambridge,
UK: Cambridge University Press, 2013b
Stetsenko A. Creativity in all of us: Dialogue with Vera
John-Steiner. In Lake R. (eds.), Constructing a Community of Thought:
Letters on the Scholarship, Teaching and Mentoring of Vera John-Steiner
(pp. 129—133). New York: Peter Lang, 2013c.
Stetsenko A. Transformative activist stance for education:
Inventing the future in moving beyond the status quo. In T. Corcoran (Ed.),
Psychology in Education: Critical Theory~Practice (pp. 181—198).
Rotterdam, The Netherlands: Sense, 2014.
Stetsenko A. Theory for and as social practice of
realizing the future: Implications from a transformative activist stance. In
Martin J. (eds.), The Wiley Handbook of Theoretical and Philosophical
Psychology: Methods, Approaches, and New Directions for Social Sciences
(pp. 102—116). New York: Wiley, 2015.
Stetsenko A. The transformative mind: Expanding
Vygotsky’s approach to development and education. New York, NY: Cambridge
University Press, 2016a.
Stetsenko A. Vygotsky’s theory of method and philosophy of
practice: Implications for trans/formative methodology. Revista Psicologia
em Estudo, 2016b, 39, 32—41.
Stetsenko A. Putting the radical notion of equality in the
service of disrupting inequality in education: Research findings and conceptual
advances on the infinity of human potential. Review of Research in
Education, 2017a, 41, 112— 135.
Stetsenko A. Science education and transformative activist
stance: Activism as a quest for becoming via authentic-authorial contribution
to communal practices. In Bryan L. (eds.), 13 Questions: Reframing
Education's Conversation: Science (pp. 33—47). NY: Peter Lang,
Stetsenko A. Research and activist projects of resistance:
The ethical-political foundations for a transformative
ethico-onto-epistemology. Learning, Culture and Social Interaction.
April 2018 a. DOI:10.1016/j.lcsi.2018.04.002
Stetsenko A. Confronting biological reductionism from a
social justice agenda: Transformative agency and activist stance. Literacy
Research: Theory, Method, & Practice, 2018b. Vol. 67, pp. 44—63.
Stetsenko A. Natureculture in a transformative worldview:
Moving beyond the “interactionist consensus.” In G. Jovanovich and C. Ratner
(Eds.), The Challenges of Cultural Psychology (pp. 37—57). London, UK:
Stetsenko A. Agentive creativity in all of us: An
egalitarian perspective from a transformative activist stance. In Connery M.C
(eds.), Vygotsky and creativity: A cultural-historical approach to play,
meaning making, and the arts (pp. 41—60). Peter Lang, 2017d.
Stetsenko A. (2019a). Radical-transformative agency:
Continuities and contrasts with relational agency and implications for
education. Frontiers in Education, 2019a, 17.
Stetsenko A. Cultural-historical activity theory meets
developmental systems perspective: Transformative activist stance and
natureculture. In Edwards A (eds.), Cultural-historical approaches to
studying learning and development: societal, institutional and personal
perspectives (pp. 249—262). London: Routledge, 2019b.
Stetsenko A. Hope, political imagination, and agency in
Marx and beyond: Explicating the transformative worldview and
ethico-ontoepistemology. Educational Philosophy and Theory, 2019c.
Stetsenko A. Creativity as dissent and resistance:
Transformative approach premised on social justice agenda. In Lebuda I. (eds.),
The Palgrave Handbook of Social Creativity (pp. 431—446). London, UK:
Stetsenko A. Personhood through the lens of
radical-transformative agency. In Sugarman J. (eds.), A Humanities Approach
to the Psychology of Personhood. London, NY: Routledge, 2020a.
Stetsenko A. Transformative-activist and social justice
approaches to the history of psychology. Oxford Research Encyclopedia,
Psychology (oxfordre.com/psychology). Oxford University Press. Subject: History
and Systems of Psychology Online Publication Date: Feb 2020b. DOI:
Stetsenko A. Radical-transformative agency: Developing a
transformative activist stance on a Marxist- Vygotskyan foundation. In Neto
A.T. (eds.), Revisiting Vygotsky for social change: Bringing together theory
and practice (pp. 31—62). London etc.: Peter Lang, 2020c.
Stetsenko A., Arievitch I. M. Vygotskian collaborative
project of social transformation: History, politics, and practice in knowledge
construction. The International Journal of Critical Psychology, 2004a,
12 (4), 58—80.
Stetsenko A., Arievitch I. The self in cultural-historical
activity theory: Reclaiming the unity of social and individual dimensions of
human development. Theory & Psychology, 2004b, 14 (4),
Stetsenko A., Arievitch I.M. Cultural-historical activity
theory: Foundational worldview and major principles. In J. Martin and S.
Kirschner (Eds.), The Sociocultural Turn in Psychology: The Contextual
Emergence of Mind and Self (pp. 231—253). New York: Columbia University
Stetsenko A., Ho P-C.G. The serious joy and the joyful
work of play: Children becoming agentive actors in co-authoring themselves and
their world through play. International Journal of Early Childhood,
2015, 47 (2), 221—234.
Stetsenko A., Selau B. Vygotsky’s approach to disability
in the context of contemporary debates and challenges: Charting the next steps
(Introduction to the Special Issue — Vygotsky’s Defectology).
Educação Revista Quadrimestral. Porto Alegre, 2018. Vol.
41, no. 3, pp. 315—324, set.-dez.
Stetsenko A., Wille Ch. Kulturhistorische Schule
[Cultural-historical school]. In Haug W.F. (eds.), Historisch-kritisches
Wörterbuch des Marxismus (Vol. 8/I, col. 378—392). Hamburg:
Sugarman J., Sokol B. Human agency and development: An
introduction and theoretical sketch. New Ideas in Psychology, 2012, 30,
van Dellen T. Learning for work, from the past, in the
present, and into the future? Studia paedagogica, 2018. Vol. 23, no. 2,
pp. 9—24. DOI:10.5817/SP2018-2-2
Vianna E., Stetsenko A. Connecting learning and identity
development through a transformative activist stance: Application in adolescent
development in a child welfare program. Human Development, 2011, 54,
Vianna E., Stetsenko A. Research with a transformative
activist agenda: Creating the future through education for social change. In J.
Vadeboncoeur (ed.), Learning in and Across Contexts: Reimagining Education.
National Society for the Studies of Education Yearbook, 2014, 113 (2),
Vianna E., Stetsenko A. Expanding student agency in the
introductory psychology course: Transformative activist stance and
critical-theoretical pedagogy. In Obeid R. (eds.), How We Teach Now: The GSTA
Guide to Student-Centered Teaching. Retrieved from the Society for the Teaching
of Psychology, 2017. web site: http://teachpsych.org/ebooks/
Vianna E., Stetsenko A. Turning resistance into passion
for knowledge with the tools of agency: Teaching-learning about theories of
evolution for social justice among foster youth. Perspectiva, 2019, 38
(4), 864—886. October-December.
Vianna E., Hougaard N., Stetsenko A. The dialectics of
collective and individual transformation: Transformative activist research in a
collaborative learning community project In A. Blunden (ed.), Collaborative
Projects (pp. 59—87). Leiden, the Netherlands: Brille, 2014.
Viveiros de Castro E. After-dinner speech at ‘Anthropology
and Science’, the 5th Decennial Conference of the Association of Social
Anthropologists of Great Britain and Commonwealth, 14 July 2003.
Wartofsky M. The child’s construction of the world and the
world’s construction of the child: From historical epistemology to historical
psychology. In Kessel F.S. (eds.), The child and other cultural
inventions (pp. 188—215). New York: Praeger, 1983.
Wynter S. Unsettling the coloniality of being/
power/truth/freedom: Towards the human, after man, its overrepresentation — An
argument. CR: The New Centennial Review, 2003, 3 (3), 257—337.
Yancy G. Through the crucible of pain and suffering:
African-American philosophy as a gift and the countering of the western
philosophical metanarrative. Educational Philosophy and Theory, 2015, 47