Previous issue (2020. Vol. 16, no. 3)
Included in Web of Science СС (ESCI)
|
|
Two Approaches to the Problem of Development in the Context of Social Interactions: L.S. Vygotsky vs J. Piaget 337
Rubtsov V.V.
Doctor of Psychology, Professor, Academician of the Russian Academy of Education, President, Head of the International UNESCO Chair «Cultural-Historical Psychology of Childhood», Moscow State University of Psychology & Education (MSUPE), Moscow, Russia
ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0002-2050-8587
e-mail: rubtsovvv@mgppu.ru
The article is devoted to the problem of development and learning in the context of social interactions. This question is investigated on the basis of the analysis of the theoretical views of L.S. Vygotsky and J. Piaget. Both J. Piaget and L.S. Vygotsky substantiated the impact of social interactions and socialization on the development of the child’s thinking, and emphasized the close connection between the development of the child and the forms of interaction between the child and adults, as well as with other children. Two different approaches to understanding the child’s developmental paths are considered in the paper: one — from the individual to the social (J. Piaget) and the other — from the social to the individual (L.S. Vygotsky). Two different developmental mechanisms, based on the interactions and relationships of the participants of the social situation, are discussed: “socio-cognitive conflict” (J. Piaget) and “emotional-semantic” (“affective-semantic”) conflict (L.V. Vygotsky). Two possible models of designing educational environments, effective for the development of children in the learning process, are described in the paper: a model based on role exchanges and children’s cooperation (“School of J. Piaget”), and a model, based on developing forms of child-adult communities and activities (“School of L.S. Vygotsky”).
Keywords: development, learning, social interactions, socio-cognitive conflict, emotional-semantic conflict, community (“obschtnost”), understanding, mutual understanding, reflection, means of interaction, thinking, “pereghivanije”
Column: Cultural-Historical Psychology: Traditions and Innovations
DOI: https://doi.org/10.17759/chp.2020160302
The basic tenets of the theory of J. Piaget. The
scientific school of J. Piaget considers the formation of intelligence as the
pivotal line in the mental development of a child, which determines the
development of all other mental processes. According to J. Piaget, the
qualitative uniqueness of each stage of cognitive development, as well as leaps
and transitions, made from one age level to another, are all determined by the
in-life formation of structures of intellectual activity, which are
age-specific.
-
Davydov V.V. Doklad na Mezhdunarodnoi konferencii
«Kul’turno-istoricheskii podhod: razvitie gumanitarnyx nauk I obrazovanie»
(sokrashhennaya stenogramma vystupleniya) [Report at the International
Conference “Cultural-Historical Approach: Development of the Humanities and
Education” (shortened transcript of speech)]. Moscow: Epsefiment, 1998, pp.
30—35. (In Russ.).
-
Davydov V.V. Vidy obobshheniya v obuchenii:
Logiko-psixologicheskie problemy postroeniya uchebnyx predmetov [Types of
generalization in training: Logical and psychological problems of building
educational subjects]. Moscow: Ped. Community of Russia, 2000, 480 p. (In
Russ.).
-
Gromyko Y.V. Rol’ vzaimoponimaniya pri reshenii uchebnyx
zadach v sovmestnoj deyatel’nosti: dis. kand. psixol. Nauk [The role of mutual
understanding in solving educational problems in joint activities: PhD Thesis].
Moscow, 1985, 168 p. (In Russ.).
-
Gromyko Y.V., Rubtsov V.V., Margolis A.A. Shkola kak
e’kosistema razvivayushhihsya detsko-vzroslyh soobshhestv: deyatel’nostnyi
podhod k proektirovaniyu shkoly budushhego [The School as Ecosystem of
Developing Child- Adult Communities: Activity Approach to Designing the School
of the Future]. Kul’turno-istoricheskaya psikhologiya = Cultural-Historical
Psychology, 2020. Vol. 16, no. 1, pp. 57—67. DOI:10.17759/chp.2020160106
(In Russ.).
-
Leontiev A. N. Filosofiya psikhologii: iz nauchnogo
naslediya [Philosophy of Psychology: from the scientific legacy]. Leontiev A.A.
(eds.). Moscow: Publishing House of MSU, 1994. 287 p. (In Russ.).
-
Martin L.M.W. Children’s problem-solving as
inter-individual outcome: Ph.D. Diss. San Diego: University of California,
1983. 164 p.
-
Obukhova L.F. Eshhe raz ob e’gocentrizme [Once again about
egocentrism]. In Obukhova L.F. (eds.), Zhan Piazhe: teoriya, e’ksperimenty,
diskussii: sb. st. [ Jean Piaget: theory, experiments, discussions].
Moscow: Gardariki, 2001, pp. 94— 105. (In Russ.).
-
Obukhova L.F. Koncepciya Zhana Piazhe: za i protiv [The
concept of Jean Piaget: pros and cons]. Moscow: Publishing House of MSU, 1981.
191 p. (In Russ.).
-
Perret-Clermont A.-N. Vliyanie idei L.S. Vygotskogo i Zh.
Piazhe na sovremennye issledovaniya problem razvitiya [The influence of the
ideas of L.S. Vygotsky and J. Piaget on modern research of developmental
problems]. In Zaretsky V.K (eds.), Nauchnaya shkola L.S. Vygotskogo:
tradicii i innovacii: materialy mezhdunar. Simpoziuma (Moscow, 27—28 iyunya
2016 g) [Scientific School of L.S. Vygotsky: Traditions and Innovations:
Materials of the International Symposium]. Moscow: Buki Vedi, 2016, pp.
44—51. (In Russ.).
-
Perret-Clermont A.-N. Rol’ social’nyx vzaimodeistvii v
razvitii intellekta detei [The role of social interactions in the development
of children’s intelligence]. Moscow: Pedagogy, 1991. 248 p. (In Russ.).
-
Piaget J. Rech’ i myshlenie rebenka [Language and Thought
of the Child]. Moscow: Pedagogy-Press, 1994. 528 p. (In Russ.).
-
Piaget J. O prirode kreativnosti [On the nature of
creativity]. In Obukhova L.F. (eds.), Zhan Piazhe: teoriya, e’ksperimenty,
diskussii: sb. st. [Jean Piaget: theory, experiments, discussions].
Moscow: Gardariki, 2001, pp. 243—252. (In Russ.).
-
Piaget J. The Psychology of Intelligence. Littlefield,
Adams & Co. Paterson, New Jersey. 1960. 182 p.
-
Piaget J. Rol’ deistviya v formirovanii myshleniya [The
role of action in the development of thinking]. In Obukhova L.F. (eds.),
Zhan Piazhe: teoriya, e’ksperimenty, diskussii: sb. st. [ Jean
Piaget: theory, experiments, discussions]. Moscow: Gardariki, 2001, pp.
199—224. (In Russ.).
-
Rubin K. H. The relationship between spatial and
communicative egocentrism in children and young and old adults. The Journal
of Genetic Psychology, 1974. Vol. 125, pp. 295—301.
-
Rubtsov V.V. Organization and development of joint actions
among children in the learning process. New York: Nova Science Publishers,
1994.
-
Rubtsov V.V. Sociogenez sovmestnogo deistviya:
vzaimoponimanie lyudei kak uslovie ponimaniya veshhei: interviyu (besedu vel V.
T. Kudrjavcev) [Sociogenesis of Joint Action: Mutual Understanding between
Individuals as a Precondition for Understanding Things. Interview (Carried out
by V.T. Kudryavtsev)]. Kul’turno-istoricheskaya psikhologiya =
Cultural-Historical Psychology, 2018. Vol. 14, no. 4, pp. 106—121.
DOI:10.17759/chp.2018140413. (In Russ.).
-
Rubtsov V.V. Social’no-geneticheskaya psihologiya
razvivajushhego obrazovaniya: deyatel’nostnyi podhod. [Socio-genetic psychology
of developing education: activity approach]. Moscow: MSPPU, 2008. 416 p. (In
Russ.).
-
Rubtsov V.V., Ageev V.V., Davydov V.V. Oprobovanie kak
mehanizm postroeniya sovmestnyh deistvii [Testing as a mechanism for
constructing joint actions]. Psihologicheskij zhurnal = Psychological
Journal,1985, no. 4, pp. 120—129. (In Russ.).
-
Rubtsov V.V., Konokotin A.V. Formation of higher mental
functions in children with special educational needs via social interaction. In
Nemerh D.J. (eds.), Evaluation and Treatment of Neuropsychologically
Compromised Children. Moscow:Academic Press, 2020, pp. 179—196.
-
Rubtsov V.V., Margolis A.A., Guruzhapov V.A.
Kul’turno-istoricheskii tip shkoly (proekt razrabotki) [Cultural and historical
type of school (design project)]. Psikhologicheskaya nauka i obrazovanie =
Psychological Science and Education, 1996. Vol. 1, no. 4. (In Russ.).
-
Rubtsov V.V., Muldarov V.K. Metod normativnoj diagnostiki
uchebno-poznavatel’nyh dejstvij u shkol’nikov [Method of normative diagnostic
assessment of educational and cognitive actions in schoolchildren]. Voprosy
psihologii = Psychology issues,1987, no. 5, pp. 147—153. (In Russ.).
-
Rubtsov V.V., Ulanovskaya I.M. Learning Аctivity as an
Effective Way to Develop Meta-Subject and Personal Competencies in Elementary
School Students. Kul’turno-istoricheskaya psikhologiya = Cultural-Historical
Psychology, 2020. Vol. 16, no. 2, pp. 51—60. DOI:10.17759/ chp.2020160207.
(In Russ.).
-
Trevarthen С., Hubley P., Sheeran L. Les activites innees
du nourisson. La Recherche = The Research, 1975. Vol. 56, pp. 447—458.
(in Fr.).
-
Turnure С. Cognitive development and role-taking ability
in boys and girls from 7 to 12. Developmental Psychology. 1975. Vol. 11
(2), pp. 202—209.
-
Vygotsky L.S. Istoriya razvitiya vysshih psihicheskih
funkcii [History of the development of higher mental functions]. Sobr. Op.: 6
vol. Vol. 3: Problemy razvitija psihiki [ Problems of the development
of the psyche]. Moscow: Pedagogy, 1983, pp. 5—328. (In Russ.).
-
Vygotsky L.S. Psikhologiya razvitiya cheloveka [Psychology
of human development]. Moscow: Eksmo-Press: Smysl, 2005. 1136 p. (In
Russ.).
-
Vygotsky L.S. Izbrannye psihologicheskie issledovanija.
[Selected psychological research]. Moscow: Publishing House of the Academy of
ped. sciences of the RSFSR, 1956. 520 p. (In Russ.).
-
Vygotsky L.S. Myshlenie i rech’ [Thinking and speech].
Moscow, 1999. (In Russ.).
-
Vygotsky L.S., Sakharov L.S. Issledovaniya obrazovaniya
ponyatii: metodika dvoinoi simulyacii [Research on the formation of concepts: a
double simulation technique]. In Gippenreiter (eds.), Hrestomatiya po
obshhei psikhologii: psikhologiya myshleniya: ucheb. posobie dlya stud. vuzov,
obuchajushhihsja pospecial’nosti «Psihologiya» [ Anthology in General
Psychology: Psychology of Thinking: study guide for university students
specialising in “Psychology”]. Moscow: Publishing House of Moscow
University, 1981, pp. 194—204. (In Russ.).
|
|
