Do I think? — yes! But do I exist?*

691

Abstract

A semiotic interpretation of «I» is given, and conditions of existence of the I outside the boundaries of sub jective reality (the possibility of «noumenal I»). We start by acknowledging the imaginary character of the I: in front of us is but a ghost, some «patterns», «compositions», «drawings», «charts» of some object X named «I» that are experience by me (who?), and some «texts» that describe the inner machinery of the former and its relations to the environment (and, among other things, to other similar ghosts of «You», «We», «They»). Further, we discover that «I», a symbolic formation within the psyche, becomes its own «object» (designatum) by mediating the currents of activity the individual generates as a physical entity. The real I is a form in which an individual exists, defined in the encounter of his/her inherent «subject-less» activity with the cultural sym¬bols (prototypes) of the I, «impressed» into the individual by culture. As a result of those encounters emerge the true subject of cognition, which constructs an image of the world (contemplative I, thinking I, receiving I, possessing I), the true subject of activity (goal-setting I, achieving I, influencing I, giving I), and the true expe¬riencing subject (enduring I, coexisting I, transcending I).

General Information

Keywords: subject-less activity, sign, hypostasise, I, real I, imaginary I.

Journal rubric: Discussions and Discourses

Article type: scientific article

For citation: Petrowskiy V.A. Do I think? — yes! But do I exist?* . Kul'turno-istoricheskaya psikhologiya = Cultural-Historical Psychology, 2011. Vol. 7, no. 3, pp. 12–26. (In Russ., аbstr. in Engl.)

References

  1. Asmolov A. G. Psihologiya lichnosti: kul'turno_istoricheskoe ponimanie razvitiya cheloveka. M., 2007.
  2. Bergson A. Opyt o neposredstvennyh dannyh soznaniya // Sobr. soch.: V 4 t. T. 1. M., 1992.
  3. Gusserl' E. Kartezianskie razmyshleniya. SPb., 1998.
  4. Gusserl' E. Idei k chistoi fenomenologii i fenomenologicheskoi filosofii. T. I. Obshee vvedenie v chistuyu fenomenologiyu. M., 1999.
  5. Dragalina_Chernaya E. G. Dedukciya sushestvovaniya.
  6. Puteshestvuya po vozmozhnym i nevozmozhnym miram // Kripkeanskaya konferenciya. M., 2011.
  7. Zaiceva A. A. Nekotorye morfologicheskie harakteristiki slov kategorii sostoyaniya v russkom i angliiskom yazykah. Internet_resurs, index.html.
  8. Zinchenko V. P. Soznanie i tvorcheskii akt. Yazyki slavyanskih kul'tur. M., 2010.
  9. Zinchenko V., Pruzhinin B., Shedrina T. Istoki kul'turnoistoricheskoi psihologii. M., 2010.
  10. Vezhbicka A. Iz knigi «Semanticheskie primitivy». Vvedenie // Semiotika. M., 1983.
  11. Morris Ch. U. Osnovaniya teorii znakov // Semiotika. M., 1983.
  12. Petrovskii V. A. Fenomen sub'ektnosti v psihologii lichnosti: Diss. ... d_ra psihol. nauk. M., 1992.
  13. Petrovskii V. A. Lichnost' v psihologii: paradigma sub'ektnosti. Rostov_n/D., 1996.
  14. Petrovskii V. A. Psihologiya: «nepredmetnost' predmeta» // Trudy yaroslavskogo metodologicheskogo seminara «Predmet psihologii». Yaroslavl', 2004.
  15. Petrovskii V. A. Motiv granicy: znakovaya priroda vlecheniya // Mir psihologii. 2008. № 3.
  16. Petrovskii V. A. Chelovek nad situaciei. M., 2010a.
  17. Petrovskii V. A. Smyslovye miry lichnosti, ili «Vo chto verit mysl'?» // Psihologiya sub'ekta i psihologiya chelovecheskogo bytiya / Pod red. V. V. Znakova, Z. I. Ryabikinoi, E. A. Sergienko. Krasnodar, 2010.
  18. Petrovskii V. A. Logika Ya. M., 2008.
  19. Stepanov Yu. S. V mire semiotiki // Semiotika. M., 1983.
  20. Haidegger M. Fenomenologiya. Germenevtika.
  21. Filosofiya yazyka. M., 1993.
  22. Hant G. O prirode soznaniya. M., 2004.
  23. Chertov L. F. Znakovost'. SPb., 1993.
  24. Shpet G. Filosofskaya kritika: otzyvy, recenzii, obzory.M., 2010.
  25. Yaroshevskii M. G., Petrovskii V. A. Psihika / Obshaya psihologiya. Slovar' / Pod red. A. V. Petrovskogo // Psihologicheskii leksikon. Enciklopedicheskii slovar': V 6 t. / Red. sost. L. A. Karpenko / Pod obsh. red. A. V. Petrovskogo. M., 2005.
  26.  

Information About the Authors

Vadim A. Petrowskiy, Doctor of Psychology, professor, Personality Psychology Chair, ordinary professor, National Research University Higher School of Economics, Corresponding Member of the Russian Academy of Education, Moscow, Russia, ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0002-5931-0738, e-mail: petrowskiy@mail.ru

Metrics

Views

Total: 1960
Previous month: 11
Current month: 4

Downloads

Total: 691
Previous month: 1
Current month: 7