Relationship between Learning and Development: Problems and Perspectives

This article discusses one of the central problems of cultural-historical psychology — the relationship between learning and development. We analyze the modern interpretation of L.S. Vygotsky’s ideas in research and practice and show that much of what the author of cultural-historical psychology proposed was somehow left behind by scientists and practitioners, whereas some of his ideas were perverted and even contradict the logic of non-classical psychology. The article emphasizes the need for research and analysis of many pressing problems of modern psychology in the context of cultural-historical psychology. For example, we suggest that the concepts of psychological and personal readiness for schooling should be interpreted in terms of the learning types classification proposed by L.S. Vygotsky. Particular attention is paid to the concept of the zone of proximal development. We point to some inconsistency between Vygotsky’s understanding of this concept and he way it is used in modern education. We believe that limiting developmental learning to the focus on the zone of proximal development to a greater extent reflects the ability to learn rather than provides evidence of development.

1. Bibler V.S. Myshlenie kak tvorchestvo [Thinking as Creativity]. Moscow Publ. Politizdat, 1975. 399 р.
2. Vygotskii L.S. Istoricheskii smysl psikhologicheskogo krizisa. Metodologicheskoe issledovanie. V Sobr. soch.: V 6 t. T. 1 [The historical meaning of the psychological crisis. Methodological research]. Moscow: Publ. Pedagogika, 1982, pp. 291—436.
3. Vygotskii L.S. Istoriya razvitiya vysshikh psikhicheskikh funktsii [The history of the development of higher mental functions]. Razvitie vysshikh psikhicheskikh funktsii [ Development of Higher Mental Functions]. Moscow Publ. Akademii pedagogicheskikh nauk, 1960. 505 p.
4. Vygotskii L.S. Pedologiya podrostka. Sobr. soch v 6 t. Tom 4 [Pedology of a teenager. Sobr. Op. 6 vol. Volume 4]. Moscow: Publ. Pedagogika 1984, рр. 5—242.
5. Vygotskii L.S. Problema vozrasta. Sobr. soch v 6 t. Tom 4 [Age problem. Sobr. Op. 6 vol. Volume 4]. Moscow: Publ. Pedagogika 1984, рр. 243—386.
6. Vygotskii L.S. Problema obucheniya I umstvennogo razvitiya v shkol’nom vozraste [The problem of learning and mental development in school age]. In Vygotskii L.S. Umstvennoe razvitie detei v protsesse obucheniya [In the book. Vygotsky L.S. Mental development of children in the learning process]. Moscow Publ. Uchpedgiz, 1935, рр. 5—18.
7. Kravtsov G.G. Metod L.S. Vygotskogo [Method L.S. Vygotsky]. Vestnik RGGU [in f. Bulletin of the Russian State Humanitarian University], 2015. Vol. 4, рр. 33—45.
8. Kravtsov G.G. Problemy vzaimosvyazi obucheniya i razvitiya [The problems of the relationship between learning and development]. In Lobastov G.V. (ed.), Pedagogicheskoe myshlenie: napravleniya, problemy, poiski [ Pedagogical thinking: directions, problems, searches]. Moscow Publ. OOO «Russkoeslovo-uchebnik», 2015, pp. 353—365.
9. Kravtsov G.G. Psikhologicheskie problemy nachal’nogo obrazovaniya [Psychological problems of primary education]. Krasnoyarsk: Publ. Krasnoyarskogo universiteta [Krasnoyarsk University], 1994, pp. 142.
10. Kravtsov G.G., Kravtsova E.E. Psikhologiya igry: kul’turno-istoricheskii podkhod [Game Psychology: Cultural- Historical Approach]. Moscow: Publ. Levb, 2017. 344 p.
11. Kravtsov O.G. Osobennosti razvitiya lichnosti deviantnykh podrostkov: kul’turno-istoricheskii aspekt [Features of personality development of deviant adolescents: cultural and historical aspect]. In Bogoyavlenskaya D.B. (ed.), Otistokov k sovremennosti 130 let organizatsii psikhologicheskogo obshchestva pri Moskovskom universitete: Sbornik materialov yubileinoi konferentsii: V 5 tomakh [ From the origins to the present 130 years of the organization of a psychological society at MoscowUniversity: Collection of materials of the anniversary conference: In 5 volumes]. 2015, pp. 458—460.
12. Kravtsov O.G. Psikhologicheskoe soderzhanie ponyatiya «deviantnoe povedenie» v kul’turno-istoricheskoi teorii [The psychological content of the concept of «deviant behavior» in the cultural-historical theory]. In Romanov A.A. (ed.), Psikhologo-pedagogicheskii poisk № 3 (39) Nauchno-metodicheskii zhurnal [ Psychological and pedagogical search No. 3 (39) Scientific and methodological journal]. Ryazan 2016, pp. 113—120.
13. Kravtsova E.E. Vygotskii L.S. I sovremennaya psikhologiya [Vygotsky L.S. and modern psychology]. Dialog [Dialog], 2017. Vol, no.1, pp. 57.
14. Kravtsova E.E. Individual’nye I kollektivnye aspekty zony blizhaishego razvitiya [Individual and collective aspects of the zone of proximal development]. In Kudryavtsev V.T. (ed.), Materialy eleventh Mezhdunarodnykh chtenii pamyati L.S. Vygotskogo (Moscow, 15—17 november 2010) «Zona blizhaishego razvitiya» v teoreticheskoi I prakticheskoi psikhologii [Proccedings of the eleventh International readings in memory of L.S. Vygotsky. «The zone of proximal development» in theoretical and practical psychology]. Moscow: Ros. gos. gumanit. un-t, In-t psikh. im. L.S. Vygotskogo, 2010, pp. 11—14.
15. Kravtsova E.E. Ponyatie vozrastnykh psikhologicheskikh novoobrazovanii v sovremennoi psikhologii razvitiya [The concept of age-related psychological neoplasms in modern developmental psychology]. Kul’turno-istoricheskaya psikhologiya [Cultural-historical psychology], 2005, no. 2, pp. 87—94. (In Russ., abstr. in Engl.)
16. Kravtsova E.E. Psikhologicheskie problemy gotovnosti detei k obucheniyu v shkole [Psychological problems of children’s readiness for school]. Nauch.-issled. in-t doshkol’nogo vospitaniya Akad. Ped. Nauk SSSR [Scientific research Institute of Preschool Education Acad. Ped. Science of the USSR]. Moscow Publ. Pedagogika, 1991. 152 p.
17. Kravtsova E.E. Kul’turno-istoricheskie osnovy zony blizhaishego razvitiya [Cultural and historical foundations of the zone of proximal development]. Psikhologicheskii zhurnal [Psychological journal], 2001. Vol. 22, no. 4, pp. 86—94.
18. Leont’ev A.N. Deyatel’nost’, soznanie, lichnost’ [Activity, consciousness, personality]. Moscow Publ. Politizdat, 1975. 304 p.
19. Podd’yakov N.N. Psikhicheskoe razvitie I samorazvitie rebenka [Mental development and self-development of the child]. Moscow: Publ. Rech’. 2010. 143 p.
20. Shopina Zh.P. Psikhologicheskie zakonomernosti formirovaniya i aktualizatsii zony blizhaishego razvitiya. Dis. kand. psikhol. nauk [Psychological patterns of the formation and updating of the zone of proximal development. Ph.D diss.]. Moscow, 2002. 190 p.