Formation of mediation in the Russian Federation

1360

Abstract

We summarized the views on the obstacles in the spread of mediation and possible measures for its development in Russia, expressed in Russian literature. We found that different and sometimes conflicting opinions and advice on mediation development in Russia, are expressed. We revealed that the attention is paid to these issues primarily by researchers from legal and related science, but opinions rationale derives from empirical experience and/or substantiated theoretical, often legal hypotheses and designs. We found that the fundamental scientific studies and surveys, justifying certain proposals, are virtually absent. We conclude that successful mediation development and building confidence to the new institution needs the measures aimed at development of mediation to be based on research evidence supporting the effectiveness of mediation for the settlement of certain disputes.

General Information

Keywords: mediation, alternative dispute resolution, conflict management, legislation on mediation

Journal rubric: Mediation

Article type: scientific article

For citation: Tyulkanov S.L. Formation of mediation in the Russian Federation. Psikhologicheskaya nauka i obrazovanie = Psychological Science and Education, 2014. Vol. 19, no. 2, pp. 34–40. (In Russ., аbstr. in Engl.)

References

  1. Allakhverdova O. V., Karpenko A. D. Mediatsiia konstruktivnoe razreshenie konfliktov [Mediation – the constructive resolution of conflicts]. Uchebnoe posobie. Sankt-Petersburg: Sankt-Petersburgskoe filosofskoe obshchestvo, 2008. 178 p.
  2. Biulleten’  Federal’nogo   Instituta   Mediatsii. 2013 god [Bulletin of the Federal Mediation Insti- tute. 2013]. Shamlikashvili T. A., ed. Moscow: Publ. ООО «Mezhregional’nyi tsentr upravlencheskogo i politicheskogo konsul’tirovaniia», 2013. 290 p.
  3. Edinyi elektronnyi katalog Rossiiskoi gosudarst- vennoi biblioteki [Single electronic catalog of the Rus- sian State Library] [Elektronnyi resurs]. URL: http:// www.rsl.ru/ru/s97/s339/ (Accessed  13.04.2014).
  4. Informatsiia o proekte «Mediatsiia v deistvii» (Kareliia) [Elektronnyi resurs] [Information on the project “Mediation in action”]. URL:http://671601.ru/ index.php/proekt-mediatsiya-v-dejstvii/o-proekte/73- projectinfo (Accessed 13.04.2014).
  5. Kalashnikova P. I. Mediatsiia v sfere grazhdanskoi iurisdiktsii [Mediation in civil jurisdiction]. Moscow: Infotropik Media; Berlin, 2011. 284 p.
  6. Lebedeva  D. P.  Mediatsiia  v  sudakh   ob- shchei iurisdiktsii [Mediation in the courts  of general jurisdiction]. Pushkinskii raionnyi sud goroda Sankt-Peterburga. Zhurnal “Sud’ia” [Jour- nal  “Judge”],  2012,  no.  3.  [Elektronnyi  resurs]. Available at: http://psh.spb.sudrf.ru/modulep. php?name=information&rid=83 (Accessed 13.04.2014).
  7. Materialy «kruglogo stola» na temu «Protsedura mediatsii: problemy zakonodatel’nogo regulirovaniia i pravoprimenitel’noi praktiki, puti ikh resheniia», pro- shedshego 23 aprelia 2013 goda v Sovete Federatsii RF [Proceedings of the “round table” on “ Mediation procedure : problems of legal regulation and prac- tice, solutions”]. [Elektronnyi resurs]. URL: http:// council.gov.ru/activity/activities/roundtables/31868 (Accessed 13.04.2014).
  8. Mediatsiia v praktike notariusa [Mediation in prac- tice notary]. Zagainova P.K., eds. Moscow: Infotropik Media, 2012. 336 p.
  9. Mediatsiia: byt’ ili ne byt’? [Mediation : To be or not to be?]. [Elektronnyi resurs]. Iuridicheskaia gazeta [Legal newspaper], 2011, no. 22, iiun’. URL: www. yur-gazeta.ru (Accessed 13.04.2014).
  10. Ponasiuk A. M. Mediatsiia i advokat: novoe napravlenie advokatskoi praktiki [Mediation and lawyer: a new direction of lawyering]. Moscow: Info- tropik Media; Berlin, 2012. 384 p.
  11. Pravovoi eksperiment “Razrabotka i aprobatsiia mekhanizmov integratsii mediatsii v grazh- danskoe sudoproizvodstvo”: itogi  2012  goda [The legal experiment “Development and testing of integration mechanisms of mediation in civil pro- ceedings”: results of 2012]. Tsentr mediatsii Ural’skoi gosudarstvennoi iuridicheskoi akademii [Elektron- nyi resurs]. URL: http://mediatsiia-ural.rf/index.php/aboutmediation (Accessed 13.04.2014).
  12. Razvitie mediatsii v Rossii: teoriia, praktika, obrazovanie: Sbornik statei [Development of media- tion in Russia: theory, practice , education: Collected papers]. Nosyrevoi E. I., eds. Moscow: Infotropik Me- dia; Berlin, 2012. 320 p.
  13. Sevast’ianov G. V., Tsyplenkova A. V. Ten- dentsii razvitiia institutsional’nykh nachal al’ter- nativnogo razreshenii sporov Trends in the de- velopment of institutional started  alternative dispute resolution].  Vestnik  VAS  RF  [Herald VAS RF], 2007, no. 3–4;  SPS  Konsul’tantPlius, pp. 63–75.
  14. Teper’ nachinaetsia samoe glavnoe [Now begins the most important]. Mediatsiia i pravo. Posrednichestvo i primirenie [Mediation and Law. Intermediation  and  conciliation],     2007,  no.  6, pp. 15.
  15. Forum na fone bol’shikh  peremen  [Forum on  the  background  of  great  change].   Mediat- siia i pravo. Posrednichestvo i primirenie [Media- tion and Law. Mediation and  conciliation],  2011, no. 22, pp. 17.
  16. Khavanskii S. N. Mediatsiia v sotsial’noi sfere: osnovy primeneniia [Mediation in the social sphere: the  basics  of  application].  Kochenovskie  chte- niia «Psikhologiia i pravo v  sovremennoi  Ros- sii»   [Kochenovskie   reading   “Psychology   and law in modern Russia”]. Moscow: MGPPU, 2012, pp. 245–246.
  17. Shamlikashvili T. A. Mediatsiia kak al’ter- nativnaia protsedura uregulirovaniia sporov. Chto neobkhodimo znat’ sud’e, chtoby kompetentno pred- lozhit’ storonam obrashchenie k protsedure mediat- sii: Uchebnoe posobie dlia vuzov, obuchaiushchikh po spetsial’nosti «Iurisprudentsiia». [Mediation as an alternative dispute resolution procedure. What you need to know the judge competent to invite the par- ties to appeal to the mediation procedure: A manual for schools, training in the specialty “Jurisprudence”]. Moscow: Mezhregional’nyi tsentr upravlencheskogo i politicheskogo konsul’tirovaniia, 2010. 160 p.
  18. Shamlikashvili T. A. Mediatsiia – mezhdistsi- plinarnaia nauka [Mediation – an interdisciplinary science]. Sbornik materialov obshcherossiiskoi nauchno-prakticheskoi distantsionnoi konferentsii “Psikhologiia i pedagogika: sovremennye metodiki i innovatsii, opyt prakticheskogo primeneniia” (Li- petsk, 27 sentiabria 2013 g.) [Collected materials All-Russian scientific-practical remote conference “Psychology and Pedagogy: modern techniques and innovations, practical experience” (Lipetsk, 27 Sep- tember, 2013]. Lipetsk: Kvatra, 2013,  pp. 5–9.
  19. Shamlikashvili T. A. Osnovy mediatsii, kak protsedury uregulirovaniia sporov [Basics of me- diation as a dispute settlement procedure]. Mos- cow: Publ. OOO “Mezhregional’nyi tsentr uprav- lencheskogo i politicheskogo konsul’tirovaniia”, 2013, 128 p.
  20. Iakovlev V. F. Nam nuzhno obresti kul’turu di- aloga [We need to find a culture of dialogue]. Me- diatsiia i pravo: Posrednichestvo i primirenie [Media- tion and Law. Intermediation and conciliation], 2012, no. 24, pp. 14–30.

Information About the Authors

S. L. Tyulkanov, Research Associate, Federal State Budget Institution “Federal Institute of Mediation”, Lecturer, Chair of mediation in the social sphere, Department of Juridical Psychology, Moscow State University of Psychology & Education, Moscow, Russia, Moscow, Russia, e-mail: tyulkanov@gmail.com

Metrics

Views

Total: 4149
Previous month: 18
Current month: 11

Downloads

Total: 1360
Previous month: 2
Current month: 1