Гулевич О.А. доктор психологических наук, Департамент психологии Факультета социальных наук, Национальный исследовательский университет «Высшая школа экономики» (ФГАОУ ВО «НИУ ВШЭ»), Москва, Россия ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0003-3806-5064 e-mail: goulevitch@mail.ru
В статье рассматривается феномен «стереотипной угрозы» – влияние стереотипов на обучение и уровень достижений представителей половых, возрастных и этнических групп. Анализируются явные и скрытые формы актуализации подобных представлений. Описываются основные механизмы их воздействия (актуализация социальной идентичности, негативные эмоции, посторонние мысли, усиление самоконтроля, сложности в обучении, уменьшение самоэффективности, усиление мотивации избегания, деидентификация с областью деятельности). Выделяются основные способы уменьшения «стереотипной угрозы», ориентированные на социальную идентичность (актуализация или формирование новой идентичности), стереотипы (от удаления стереотипных стимулов до демонстрации позитивных моделей поведения), задание (изменение инструкции) и индивидуальные особенности человека (повышение самоэффективности, обучение копинг-стратегиям). Отмечается, что знание закономерностей воздействия «стереотипной угрозы» позволяет повысить эффективность обучения.
* Работа выполнена при поддержке гранта РГНФ № 13-06-00680 "Почему психологи не знают математику? Влияние профессиональных стереотипов на качество университетского образования"
Процесс обучения включает в себя общение между людьми. Как следствие
передача знаний сопровождается целым рядом социально-психологических эффектов.
К их числу относится «самосбывающееся пророчество» – тенденция человека
оправдывать ожидания, сформированные по отношению к нему. Чаще всего источником
ожиданий является партнер по общению [40]. Однако в некоторых случаях человек
сталкивается с определенными ожиданиями так часто, что постепенно запоминает их
и следует им даже при отсутствии партнера.
Литература
Abrams D., Crisp R.J., Marques S., Fagg E., Bedford L., Provias D.
Threat inoculation: experienced and imagined intergenerational contact prevents
stereotype threat effects on older people’s math performance // Psychology and
Aging. 2008. Vol. 23.
Abrams D., Eller A., Bryant J. An age apart: the effects of
intergenerational contact and stereotype threat on performance and intergroup
bias // Psychology and Aging. 2006. Vol. 21.
Appel M., Kronberger N., Aronson J. Stereotype threat impairs
ability building: effects on test preparation among women in science and
technology // European Journal of Social Psychology. 2011. Vol. 41.
Armenta B.E. Stereotype boost and stereotype threat effects: the
moderating role of ethnic identification // Cultural Diversity and Ethnic
Minority Psychology. 2010. Vol. 16.
Aronson J., Quinn D.M., Spencer S.J. Stereotype threat and the
academic underperformance of minorities and women // Prejudice: The Target`s
Perspectives. Academic Press, 1998.
Beilock S.L., Jettison W.A., Rydell
R.J., McConnell A.R, Cair T.H.
On the causal mechanisms of stereotype threat: can skills that
don't rely heavily on working memory still be threatened? // Personality and
Social Psychology Bulletin. 2006. Vol. 32.
Bleeker M.M., Jacobs J.E. Achievement in math and science: do
mothers' beliefs matter 12 years later? // Journal of Educational Psych. 2004.
Vol. 96.
Boucher K.L., Rydell R.J., Van Loo K.J., Rydell M.T. Reducing
stereotype threat in order to facilitate learning // European Journal of Social
Psychology. 2012. Vol. 42.
Cadinu M., Maass A., Frigerio S., Impagliazzo L., Latinotti
S. Stereotype threat: the effect of expectancy on performance//
European Journal of Social Psychology. 2003. Vol. 33.
Cadinu M., Maass A., Lombardo M., Frigerio S. Stereotype threat: the
moderating role of locus of control beliefs // European Journal of Social
Psychology. 2006. Vol. 36.
Croizet J.-C., Desprus G., Gauzins M.-E., Huguet P., Leyens J.-P., Meat
A. Stereotype threat undermines intellectual performance by triggering a
disruptive mental load // Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin. 2004.
Vol. 30.
Davies P.G., Spencer S.J., Steele C.M. Clearing the air:
identity safety moderates the effects of stereotype threat on women's
leadership aspirations // Journal of Personality and Social Psychology. 2005.
Vol. 88.
Desrichard O., Kopetz C. A threat in the elder: the impact of
task-instructions, self-efficacy and performance expectations on memory
performance in the elderly // European Journal of Social Psychology. 2005. Vol.
35.
Dutrevis M., Croizet J.-C. Reputation of intellectual inferiority
undermines memory efficiency among college students // Current Research in
Social Psychology. 2005. Vol. 10. № 8.
Forbes C.E., Schmader T. Retraining attitudes and stereotypes to
affect motivation and cognitive capacity under stereotype threat // Journal of
Personality and Social Psychology. 2010. Vol. 99.
Ford Т.Е., Ferguson M.A., Brooks J.L., Hagadone K.M. Coping sense of
humor reduces effects of stereotype threat on women's math performance //
Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin. 2004. Vol. 30.
Gonzales P.M., Blanton H., Williams K.J. The effects of stereotype
threat and double-minority status on the test performance of Latino women //
Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin. 2002. Vol. 28.
Grimm L.R., Markman A.B., Maddox W.T., Baldwin G.C. Stereotype
threat reinterpreted as a regulatory mismatch // Journal of Personality and
Social Psychology. 2009. Vol. 96.
Hess T.M., Hinson J.T. Age-related variation in the influences of
aging stereotypes on memory in adulthood // Psychology and Aging. 2006. Vol.
21.
Hoyt C.L., Blascovich J. The role of leadership self-efficacy and
stereotype activation on cardiovascular, behavioral and self-report responses
in leadership domain // The Leadership Quarterly. 2010. Vol. 21.
Huguet P., Regner I. Stereotype threat among schoolgirls in
quasi-ordinary classroom circumstances // Journal of Educational Psychology.
2007. Vol. 99.
Inzlicht M., Kang S.K. Stereotype threat spillover: how coping with
threats to social identity. Affects aggression, eating, decision making and
attention // Journal of Personality and Social Psychology. 2010. Vol. 99.
Johns M., Inzlicht M., Schmader T. Stereotype threat and executive
resource depletion: examining the influence of emotion regulation // Journal of
Experimental Psychology: General. 2008. Vol. 137.
Keller J., Dauenheimer D. Stereotype threat in the classroom:
dejection mediates the disrupting threat effect on women's math performance //
Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin. 2003. Vol. 29.
Klein O., Pohl S., Ndagijimana C. The influence of intergroup
comparisons on Africans’ intelligence test performance in a job selection
context // Journal of Psychology. 2007. Vol. 141.
Kray L.J., Thompson L., Galinsky A. Battle of the sexes: gender
stereotype confirmation and reactance in negotiations // Journal of
Personality and Social Psychology. 2001. Vol. 80.
Levy B.R., Leifheit-Limson E. The stereotype-matching effect:
greater influence on functioning when age stereotypes correspond to outcomes //
Psychology and Aging. 2009. Vol.24.
Maass A., Cadinu M. Stereotype threat: When minority members
underperform // European Review of Social Psychology. 2003. Vol. 24.
Maass A., D’Ettole C., Cadinu M. Checkmate? The role of gender
stereotypes in the ultimate intellectual sport // European Journal of Social
Psychology. 2008. Vol. 38.
Martiny S.E., Roth J., Jelenec P., Steffens M.C., Croizet J.-C. When
a new group identity does harm on the spot: stereotype threat in newly created
groups // European Journal of Social Psychology. 2012. Vol. 41.
Marx D.M., Roman J.S. Female role models: protecting women’s math
test performance // Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin. 2002. Vol. 28.
Marx D.M., Stapel D.A. It's all in the timing: measuring emotional
reactions to stereotype threat before and after taking a test // European
Journal of Social Psychology. 2006. Vol. 36.
McIntyre R.B., Lord C.G., Gresky D.M., Ten Eyck L.L., Frye G.D.J., Bond,
Jr.C.F. A social impact trend in the effects of role models on alleviating
women`s mathematics stereotype threat // Current Research in Social Psychology.
2005. Vol. 10. № 9.
McIntyre R.B., Paulson R.M., Taylor C.A., Morin A.L., Lord C.G.
Effects of role model deservingness on overcoming performance deficits induced
by stereotype threat // European Journal of Social Psychology. 2011. Vol. 41.
McIntyre R.B., Paulson R.M., Lord C.G. Alleviating women's
mathematics stereotype threat through salience of group achievements //
Journal of Experimental Social Psychology. 2003. Vol. 39.
Muzzatti B., Agnoli F. Gender and mathematics: attitudes and
stereotype threat susceptibility in Italian children // Developmental
Psychology. 2007. Vol. 43.
Nguyen H.-H.D., Ryan A.M. Does stereotype threat affect test
performance of minorities and women? A meta-analysis of experimental evidence
// Journal of Applied Psychology. 2008. Vol. 93.
O'Brien L.T., Crandall C.S. Stereotype threat and arousal: effects
on women's math performance // Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin.
2003. Vol. 29.
Phelan J.E., Rudman L.A. Reactions to ethnic deviance: the role of
backlash in racial stereotype maintenance // Journal of Personality and Social
Psychology. 2010. Vol. 99.
Pinel E.C. Stigma consciousness in intergroup contexts: the power of
conviction // Journal of Experimental Social Psychology. 2002. Vol. 38.
Rosenthal H.E.S., Crisp R.J. Reducing stereotype threat by blurring
intergroup boundaries // Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin. 2006. Vol.
32.
Rosenthal H.E.S., Crisp R.J., Suen M.-W. Improving performance
expectancies in stereotypic domains: task relevance and the reduction of
stereotype threat // European Journal of Social Psychology. 2007. Vol. 37.
Rydell R.J., McConnell A.R., Beilock S.L. Multiple social identities
and stereotype threat: imbalance, accessibility, and working memory // Journal
of Personality and Social Psychology. 2009. Vol. 96.
Rydell R.J., Rydell M.T., Boucher K.L. The effect of negative
performance stereotypes on learning // Journal of Personality and Social
Psychology. 2010. Vol. 99.
Schmader Т., Johns M. Converging evidence that stereotype threat
reduces working memory capacity // Journal of Personality and Social
Psychology. 2003. Vol. 85.
Schmader T., Johns M., Forbes C. An integrated process model of
stereotype threat effects on performance // Psychological Review. 2008. Vol.
115.
Shapiro J.R., Neuberg S.L. From stereotype threat to stereotype
threats: implications of a multi-threat framework for causes, moderators,
mediators, consequences, and interventions // Personality and Social Psychology
Review. 2007. Vol.11.
Shih M., Ambady N., Bicheson J.A., Fujita K., Gray H.M. Stereotype
performance boosts: the impact of self-relevance and the manner of stereotype
activation // Journal of Personality and Social Psychology. 2002. Vol. 83.
Stone J. Battling doubt by avoiding practice: the effects of
stereotype threat on self-handicapping in White athletes // Personality and
Social Psychology Bulletin. 2002. Vol. 28.
Von Hippel C., Issa M., Ma R., Stokes A. Stereotype threat:
antecedents and consequences for working women // European Journal of Social
Psychology. 2011. Vol. 41.