Child Participation in Russia: Theoretical and Practical Developments

The article analyzes the development of practice and development of theoretical grounds for child participation in contemporary Russia. Children’s participation is considered as an interdisciplinary field of research, and as the practice of taking into account children’s views at different levels: in everyday life, in family and in local community, in organizations and in self-government bodies. Children are considered as reflective actors: co-authors of research and evaluation of social projects. The analysis uses publications describing the practice and results of researching children’s participation; key legal documents; materials from expert discussions, as well as data on relevant international experience. Data on the views of various stakeholders — specialists, parents, and children themselves — on the issues of child participation are compared and contrasted. The authors conclude that there is no unified system of child participation in Russia, and the most common approaches to its study vary in their methodological groundings. The current situation does not pose serious controversy and threats to the development of children’s participation; it may be favorable for the diversification and competition of approaches to development of child participation practices and their study. Recommendations are given on the themes of further applied research.

1. Abrosimova E.E., Bukhtiyarova I.N., Filipova A.G. Uchastie detei v reshenii voprosov, zatragivayushchikh ikh interesy: analiz regional’nykh obrazovatel’nykh meropriyatii i materialov SMI [Children’s participation in issues affecting their interests: analysis of regional educational events and media materials]. Oikumena. Regionovedcheskie issledovaniya = Ecumene. Regional studies, 2019, no. 3, pp. 50—64. DOI:10.24866/1998-6785/2019-3/50-64 (In Russ.)
2. Archakova T.O., Garifulina E.Sh. Deti v roli issledovatelei, otsenshchikov i soavtorov sotsial’nykh praktik: opyt konkursa «Golos rebenka: Deti kak eksperty opyta» [Children as researchers, evaluators and co-authors of social practices: experience of the Contest “Voice of the Child: Children as Experiences Experts”]. Materialy konferentsii «Detskie initsiativy — put’ v budushchee»: effektivnye praktiki podderzhki detskikh sotsial’nykh initsiativ, uchastiya detei v prinyatii reshenii, zatragivayushchikh ikh interesy [Elektronnyi resurs] [Materials of the conference “Children’s Initiatives — the Way to the Future”: effective practices for supporting children’s social initiatives, children’s participation in decision-making affecting their interests]. Moscow: Fond podderzhki detei v trudnykh zhiznennykh situatsiyakh [Fund to Support Children in Difficult Life Situations], 2019, pp. 56—76. (Accessed: 30.01.2020) Available at: https://www.fond-detyam.ru/upload/iblock/5e7 Детские%20инициативы%20-%20путь%20в%20 будущее.pdf (Accessed: 30.01.2020).
3. Volkov V.V., Kharkhordin O.V. Teoriya praktik [The Practice Theory]. Saint-Petersburg: Izdatel’stvo Evropeiskogo universiteta v Sankt-Peterburge [Publishing House of the European University in St. Petersburg], 2008. 298 p.
4. Vosstanovitel’nye programmy v rabote s det’mi i sem’yami, nakhodyashchimisya v trudnoi zhiznennoi situatsii (sbornik materialov) [Recovery programs for working with children and families in difficult situations. Work with difficult cases (collection of materials)]. Moscow: MOO Tsentr “Sudebno-pravovaya reforma” [MOO Center “Judicial and Legal Reform”], 2018. 142 p.
5. Garifulina E.Sh. Podkhody k uchetu mneniya rebenka pri prinyatii reshenii, zatragivayushchikh ego interesy [Approaches to taking the child’s opinion into account when making decisions that affect their interests]. Vebinar «Podkhody k uchetu mneniya rebenka pri prinyatii reshenii, zatragivayushchikh ego interesy pri organizatsii zashchity prav detei, v tom chisle spetsialistami organov opeki i popechitel’stva» [Elektronnyi resurs] [Webinar “Approaches to taking a child’s opinion into account when making decisions that affect their interests in organizing the protection of children’s rights including by specialists from the guardianship and guardianship authorities”]. Moscow: Moscow State University of Psychology & Education, 2017. Available at: http://deti.timchenkofoundation.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/12/Podkhody-k-uchetu-mneniya-rebenka-pri-prinyatii-reshenii-zatragivayushchikh-ego-interesy.pdf (Accessed: 30.01.2020).
6. Garifulina E.Sh. Realizatsiya prava rebenka byt’ uslyshannym: vvedenie v temu [Elektronnyi resurs] [Implementation of the child’s right to be heard: introduction to the subject]. Available at: http:// deti.timchenkofoundation.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/ Garifulina-E_Fond-Timchenko_Uchastie-detei_120918.pdf (Accessed: 30.01.2020).
7. «Golos rebenka»: zachem on nam i chto my ot nego zhdem? [“The voice of a child”: why do we need it and what do we expect from it?] Akvatoriya partnerstva [Aquatory of Partnership] (Ryazan’, November, 13-14, 2019). Available at: http://timchenkofoundation.org/novosti/akvatorija-partnjorstva/ (Accessed: 30.01.2020).
8. Desyatiletie detstva: neobkhodimo uchityvat’ mnenie obshchestvennikov i samikh detei [Elektronnyi resurs] [Decade of Childhood: it is necessary to take into account the opinion of social activists and children themselves]. Available at: https://www.oprf.ru/ru/about/interaction/region_chambers/431/2527/ newsitem/46309 (Accessed: 30.01.2020).
9. Detstvo XXI veka v sotsiogumanitarnoi perspektive: novye teorii, yavleniya i ponyatiya. Nauchnaya monografiya [The childhood of XXI century in the socio-humanistic perspective: new theories, phenomena, and concepts. Scientific monograph]. In Maiorova-Shcheglova S.N. Moscow, 2017. 203 p.
10. Doklad po itogam monitoringa effektivnosti realizatsii Natsional’noi strategii deistvii v interesakh detei na 2012—2017 gody [Report on the Results of Implementation Efficiency of the National Action Strategy for Children 2012—2017]. T. 2. In Rubtsova V.V. (ets.). Moscow: Izdanie Soveta Federatsii, 2018. 192 p.
11. Zubova O.G. Uchastie detei v prinyatii reshenii: rossiiskii nauchnyi diskurs (analiz publikatsii za 2009—2019 gg.) [Children’s participation in decision-making: Russian scientific discourse (analysis of publications for 2009—2019)] // Uchastie detei v reshenii voprosov, zatragivayushchikh ikh interesy: sovremennoe sostoyanie, problemy i perspektivy: materialy mezhdunar. nauchnoi konf. (Vladivostok, 9—11 oktyabrya 2019 g.) [Participation of children in solving issues affecting their interests: current state, problems and prospects: proceedings of the international scientific conference, Vladivostok, October 9—11, 2019]. Saint-Petersburg: Asterion, 2019, pp. 31—34.
12. Il’ina O.Yu. Interesy rebenka v semeinom prave Rossiiskoi Federatsii [The interests of a child in Family Law of the Russian Federation]. Moscow: Izdatel’skii dom «Gorodets» [Publishing house “Gorodets”], 2006. 192 p.
13. Kaz’min A.M. Uchastie: teoreticheskie aspekty i otsenka v praktike rannei pomoshchi [Elektronnyi resurs] [Participation: Theoretical Aspects and Assessment in Early Intervention Practice]. Klinicheskaya i spetsial’naya psikhologiya = Clinical Psychology and Special Education, 2015. Vol. 4, no. 2, pp. 115— 127. Available at: https://psyjournals.ru/psyclin/2015/n2/Kazmin.shtml (Accessed: 01.10.2020). (In Russ., аbstr. in Engl.)
14. Kalabikhina I.E., Iontseva S.V., Kozlov V. Analiz modelei uchastiya detei v protsessakh prinyatiya reshenii po voprosam, zatragivayushchim interesy rebenka (na primere rossiiskikh gorodov, prisoedinivshikhsya k initsiative YuNISEF «Goroda, dobrozhelatel’nye k detyam») [Elektronnyi resurs] [Analysis of models of children’s participation in decision-making processes on issues affecting the interests of the child (on the example of Russian cities that joined the UNICEF initiative “Cities Friendly to Children”)]. Available at: https://publications.hse.ru/mirror/pubs/share/folder/6m2ui85k63/direct/60563832 (Accessed: 30.01.2020).
15. Kalabikhina I.E., Kuchmaeva O.V. Problemy i perspektivy monitoringa uchastiya detei v realizatsii «Natsional’noi strategii deistvii v interesakh detei na 2012-2017 gg. » [Elektronnyi resurs] [Problems and prospects of monitoring children’s participation in the implementation of the “National Strategy of Action for Children for 2012-2017”]. Zhurnal issledovanii sotsial’noi politiki = Journal of Social Policy Research, 2016, no. 4, pp. 507—520.
16. Konovalov A.Yu. Monitoring deyatel’nosti shkol’nykh sluzhb primireniya za 2018 god, provedennyi v ramkakh Vserossiiskoi assotsiatsii vosstanovitel’noi mediatsii [Monitoring of school reconciliation services in 2018, conducted within the framework of the all-Russian Association of Restorative Mediation]. Vestnik vosstanovitel’noi yustitsii = Bulletin of restorative justice, 2019, no. 16, pp. 149—181.
17. Kochnev S.V., Vasil’eva N.V. Uchastie detei i molodezhi v prinyatii obshchestvenno znachimykh reshenii: metodicheskoe posobie [The participation of children and youth in making socially significant decisions: a methodological guide]. Moscow: Publ. OOO «RUTA», 2013. 138 p.
18. Kristi N. Konflikty kak sobstvennost’ [Conflicts as property]. In Konovalov A. Vosstanovitel’naya yuvenal’naya yustitsiya. Moscow: Publ. MOO Tsentr «Sudebno-pravovaya reforma», 2007, pp. 40—58.
19. Maiorova—Shcheglova S.N. Osnovnye issledovatel’skie podkhody v prikladnoi sotsiologii dlya otsenki uchastiya detei v prinyatii reshenii [Main research approaches in applied sociology for assessing children’s participation in decision-making]. Uchastie detei v reshenii voprosov, zatragivayushchikh ikh interesy: sovremennoe sostoyanie, problemy i perspektivy: materialy mezhdunar. nauchnoi konf. [Participation of children in solving issues affecting their interests: current state, problems and prospects: materials of the international journal. scientific Conf.] (Vladivostok, October 9—11, 2019). Saint-Petersburg: Asterion, 2019, pp. 43—45.
20. Malovichko I.S. Pogorelova O.P. Deti-volontery v shkol’noi sluzhbe primireniya: metody i formy privlecheniya, organizatsii, obucheniya, motivatsii i podderzhki (iz opyta Volgogradskoi oblasti). Metodicheskoe posobie [Children-volunteers in the school reconciliation service: methods and forms of involvement, organization, training, motivation and support (from the experience of the Volgograd region)]. Moscow: Pabl. MOO Tsentr «Sudebno-pravovaya reforma», 2017. 23 p.
21. Merkul’ I.A., Busygina N.P. Khochu vse znat’ o budushchem priemnom roditele [Elektronnyi resurs] [I want to know everything about my future foster parent]. Available at: http://deti.timchenkofoundation.org/ wp-content/uploads/ MGOU-OTsSZS.pdf (Accessed: 30.01.2020).
22. Metodiki i instrumenty dlya raboty s det’mi i sem’yami v trudnoi zhiznennoi situatsii v orientirovannom na reshenie podkhode [Elektronnyi resurs] [Methods and tools for working with children and families in difficult situations in a solution-oriented approach]. Moscow: BDF «Viktoriya», 2019. Available at: https://victoriacf.ru/wp-content/uploads/2012/12/Instrumenty-dlya-sotsial-noj-raboty-v-ORKT.pdf (Accessed: 30.01.2020).
23. Obshchestvennyi monitoring organizatsii dlya detei-sirot i detei, ostavshikhsya bez popecheniya roditelei: Metodicheskie rekomendatsii po provedeniyu monitoringa sootvetstviya organizatsii postanovleniyu Pravitel’stva Rossiiskoi Federatsii ot 24 maya 2014 g. no. 481 [Elektronnyi resurs] [Public monitoring of organizations for orphaned children and children left without parental care: guidelines for monitoring compliance of organizations with the Decree of the Government of the Russian Federation No. 481 of May 24, 2014]. Moscow: BF «Volontery v pomoshch’ detyam-sirotam» [Charitable Fund “Volunteers to Help Orphans”], 2018. 66 p. Available at: https://otkazniki.ru/files/metod_2018.pdf (Accessed: 30.01.2020).
24. Ostrova utopii: pedagogicheskoe i sotsial’noe proektirovanie poslevoennoi shkoly (1940—1980-ye). Kollektivnaya monografiya [Islands of utopia: pedagogical and social design of post-war schools (1940s—1980s). Collective monograph.]. Moscow: Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie [New Literary Review], 2015. 720 p.
25. Otrokov O.Yu., Pupykin R.A. Molodezhnoe samoupravlenie v Rossii na sovremennom etape: osnovnye priznaki, funktsii i urovni deyatel’nosti [Youth self-government in Russia at the present stage: main features, functions and levels of activity]. Politematicheskii setevoi elektronnyi nauchnyi zhurnal Kubanskogo gosudarstvennogo agrarnogo universiteta = Polythematic network electronic scientific journal of Kuban state agrarian University, 2017, no. 129, pp. 443—457.
26. Poyasnitel’nyi doklad k Rekomendatsii Rec (2005)5 Komiteta ministrov stranam-uchastnitsam Soveta Evropy po probleme prav detei, prozhivayushchikh v internatnykh uchrezhdeniyakh [Elektronnyi resurs] [The explanatory report to Recommendation Rec (2005)5 Of the Committee of Ministers to the member States of the Council of Europe on the rights of children living in residential institutions]. Available at: https://rm.coe.int/CoERMPublicCommonSearchServices/DisplayDCTMContent?documentId=09000016 8046ce29 (Accessed: 30.01.2020).
27. Prakticheskie trebovaniya k rabote po uchastiyu detei [Elektronnyi resurs] [Practical work requirements for the participation of children]. Murmansk: RPO «Spasem Detei» [RPO “Save the Children”], 2017. Available at: http://ozenka.info/usefuldata/metodics/prakticheskie_trebovaniya_k_rabote_po_uchastiyu_ detey /196_file_1.pdf (Accessed: 30.01.2020).
28. Proekt «Pravo byt’ uslyshannym: uchastie detei i molodezhi v razvitii sotsial’noi politiki v Rossiiskoi Federatsii»: informatsionno-metodicheskie materialy po itogam raboty s nesovershennoletnimi det’mi kategorii riska v trekh regionakh Rossiiskoi Federatsii (2010—2014) [Project “The Right to be heard: participation of children and youth in the development of social policy in the Russian Federation”: information and methodological materials on the results of work with underage children at risk in three regions of the Russian Federation (2010-2014)]. Ekaterinburg: Pabl. AMB, 2013.
29. Remorenko I.M. Deyatel’nost’ obshchestvenno-aktivnykh shkol i uchenicheskoe samoupravlenie [Activity of socially active schools and students’ self-government]. Sibirskii pedagogicheskii zhurnal = Siberian pedagogical journal, 2018, no. 5, pp. 104—112.
30. Romanova E., Kosheleva N. Neobychnye deti — obychnoe issledovanie [Elektronnyi resurs] [Unusual children — ordinary research]. Konkurs issledovatel’skikh grantov Fonda Timchenko «Golos rebenka: deti kak eksperty opyta» [Competition of research grants of the Timchenko Foundation “Voice of the Child: Children as Experiences Experts”]. Moscow, 2019. Available at: http://deti.timchenkofoundation.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/Rasprav’-kryl’ya.pdf (Accessed: 30.01.2020).
31. Rusakovskaya O.A., Safuanov F.S., Kharitonova N.K. Faktory, podlezhashchie ustanovleniyu pri provedenii ksppe po sporam o vospitanii detei razdel’no prozhivayushchimi roditelyami [Elektronnyi resurs] [Factors to be Established During CFPPE in Disputes about Parenting by Estranged Parents]. Psikhologicheskaya nauka i obrazovanie = Psychological Science and Education, 2011. Vol. 3, no. 1, pp. 60—70. (In Russ., аbstr. in Engl.)
32. Skrypnikova E.M. Rol’ vzroslogo v realizatsii uchastiya detei v prinyatii reshenii [Adult Role in Implementing the Involvement of Children Decision-Making]. Sibirskii pedagogicheskii zhurnal = Siberian Pedagogical Journal, 2014, no. 6, pp. 50—53. (In Russ., аbstr. in Engl.)
33. Terekhina N.V. Vedushchaya deyatel’nost’ podrostkovogo vozrasta s tochki zreniya osnovnykh zadach razvitiya [The Leading Activity of the Adolescence in Terms of the Main Developmental Objectives]. Psikhologicheskaya nauka i obrazovanie = Psychological Science and Education, 2010. Vol. 15, no. 5, pp. 43—51.
34. Shamrova D.P., Tikhomirova A.V., Podushkina T.G. Sistemnyi analiz dokazatel’stv vliyaniya uchastiya detei v otsenke sotsial’nykh programm na ikh psikhologicheskoe razvitie [Elektronnyi resurs] [System analysis of evidences of the impact of child involvement in evaluating social programs on their psychological development]. Sovremennaya zarubezhnaya psikhologiya = Journal of Modern Foreign Psychology, 2016. Vol. 5, no. 2, pp. 39—50. DOI:10.17759/jmfp.2016050205
35. Shmidt V.R. Formatsiya diskursov prav rebenka: ot politiki paternalizma k kontrolyu nad gosudarstvom [Formation of child rights discourses: from the policy of paternalism to state control]. In Yarskoi-Smirnovoi E.R., Antonovoi E.P. Sotsial’naya politika i mir detstva v sovremennoi Rossii [Social policy and the world of childhood in modern Russia]. Moscow: OOO «Variant», 2009, pp. 6—150.
36. Cremin H. Peer mediation: Citizenship and social inclusion revisited. Open University Press. UK, Berkshire. 2015.
37. Evaluation of legislation, policy and practice on child participation in the European Union (EU). Final Report. 2015 [Electronic resource]. Available at: https://op.europa.eu/en/publication-detail/-/ publication/3f3c50b2-6a24-465e-b8d1-74dcac7f 8c42 (Accessed: 30.01.2020).
38. General Comment No. 12, 2009. The right of the child to be heard [Electronic resource]. Available at: http:// www2.ohchr.org/english/bodies/crc/docs/AdvanceVersions/ CRC-C-GC-12.pdf (Accessed: 30.01.2020).
39. Lansdown G. The evolving capacities of the child. Innocenti Research Centre, UNICEF/Save the Children, Florence. 2005 [Electronic resource]. Available at: https://www.unicef-irc.org/publications/pdf/ evolving-eng.pdf (Accessed: 30.01.2020).
40. Percy-Smith B., Thomas N. Introduction. A Handbook of Children and Young People’s Participation. Perspectives from theory and practice. In B. Percy-Smith, N. Thomas (eds.). Oxon, UK: Routledge, 2010.
41. Woodhead M. Foreword. A Handbook of Children and Young People’s Participation. Perspectives from theory and practice. In B. Percy-Smith, N. Thomas (eds.). Oxon, UK: Routledge, 2010.